The Ecologist




 
Polytunnel
More articles about
Related Articles

Let's use the Gulf Stream to increase UK food production

Adam York

9th June, 2010

Our current patterns of veg growing mostly ignore the fact that the UK is much warmer than it should be for its latitude - and we could exploit that

Amidst rising awareness of food and energy challenges several realities about the UK are becoming clear to environmentally-minded people.

First, forestry is much neglected; secondly big arable (i.e. grain) and animal farming dominates UK food production; and thirdly our importation of fresh vegetables remains substantial and a point of vulnerability.

I believe we can work towards a significant solution to the latter - namely cropping in the winter months in our mild coastal areas. My own experience of market gardening has certainly convinced me of the potential for seasonal extension without resorting to trashing the soil.

From the first serious frosts in perhaps November leafy cropping ceases in most areas until the spring. This is due to temperature but also low light levels and short days. We are essentially a country at a high northern latitude but blessed with major exposure to the Gulf Stream. The warm seas of the latter mean that several coastal strip areas experience only limited and light frosts in most years. This is a significant opportunity.

The key areas, many of which also have fertile soil, run from Cornwall to Kent, the Isle of Wight, the Channels Isles, Pembrokeshire, the Gower Peninsula and Strangford Loch in County Down. While there is still production in these areas, volumes and morale amongst producers are low. Traditional markets have shrunk as cheap fuel enabled access to cheaper production further south. Tastes have also favoured 'Ratatouille' crops in recent years. Power has moved from producers to multiple retailers with efficient logistics.

Learning to love polytunnels

While the warmed area may only run one or two miles inland, large amounts of produce can be raised in relatively small areas. The current sources of crops (e.g. Andalucia, Portugal, Sicily, Morocco, Kenya) will always use significantly more energy to get to our plates. Produce grown in the Rift Valley is particularly destructive, and makes further serious conflict there likely.

The solution is not as straightforward as merely moving production from one location back to Blighty. We must also grow and eat seasonal crops, so french beans and aubergines won’t work in Cornwall in March but cauliflowers and globe artichokes will.

If we allow ourselves the significant leg-up of polytunnels or glasshouses in those sites sheltered enough to survive the worst south-westerly winds then the cropping range is further expanded. For example, spinach growing moves south in the autumn because it is cheaper, but could be harvested here in the UK under protected conditions.

The public antipathy towards polytunnels is unfortunate because, as Eliot Coleman and other pioneers have shown, they are very energy efficient. They gain much from providing a simple barrier to wind chill, but also use recyclable materials and are cost effective. With 70 million people to feed, can we do without them?

Sources of soil fertility are also important under protected conditions, often being brought in from outside the growing system. The likely demise of cheap nitrate and phosphate fertilisers will preclude their use, so efficient composting should be encouraged and reuse of sewage nutrients and energy has to be resolved. Throwing them away won’t remain an option.

A change in thinking

Some first steps might involve moving all salad production back to the UK (but no Iceberg lettuces in December!), forsaking Spanish 'broccoli' (actually calabrese) in favour of purple sprouting brocolli, and making courgettes, asparagus and broad beans significant polytunnel crops. We would certainly have to accept less choice, but then this would be a seasonal menu: the acclaimed world cuisines of Lebanon and Italy would not think it a problem. Few restaurants in the UK now have any notion of a predominantly seasonal menu.

So what to do. Policy measures could immediately help, but continued oil prices at $100+ a barrel might well force our hand. However, acting before that happens is much more prudent, as horticultural units cannot be switched on overnight.

The planning system could be used in several constructive ways. First, by identifying useful coastal areas and applying agricultural restrictions on land use. We cannot afford the inequity of second homes when we need growers far more. Secondly, by using existing support payments to favour production based on a balance of nutrients produced and inputs consumed. Thirdly, by modelling growing scenarios around oil and nitrate fertiliser at higher prices and noting production effects.

We need to act now. Societies that chopped down their forests, pandered to their elites and had little foresight or planning, as Jared Diamond has shown in his book Collapse, have always failed. A seasonal, sustainable cuisine would be something to be proud of.

Adam York is one of founders at Unicorn Grocery Ltd and Glebelands Market Garden Ltd, Manchester. He is also a committee member of the Organic Growers Alliance and recently moved to coastal SW Wales

Add to StumbleUpon
  READ MORE...
HOW TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE
Saving and rebuilding community shops
Mourning the loss of your beloved local shop? With a little help from the Community Shops Network, you can set up and run your own shop and post office...
NEWS
FSA accused of running PR exercise for GM industry
Member of steering group resigns claiming the Food Standard Agency's (FSA) £500,000 public dialogue on genetically modified (GM) food is ignoring key issues about GM feed and labelling
NEWS
Small-scale beekeepers threatened by colony losses
Continuing high winter losses in bee colonies is prompting fears about future of hobby beekeeping
GREEN LIVING
Peat free compost: why to use and which to buy
An avid gardener road-tests two brands of peat free compost, and gives you a recipe to make your own
GREEN LIVING
Creating a Forest Garden: working with nature to grow edible crops
Excerpts from the new book telling you everything you need to know about this novel way to grow edible crops - where nature does most of the work for you.

 

Previous Articles...

Users Comments

Re: Let's use the Gulf Stream to increase UK food production
Posted By paulross 1 June 10, 2010 10:22:39 AM

I agree entirely with your sentiment - you do not even mention the potential for heating or lighting tunnels in winter - even if grid electricity were used, there is scope of a fair amount of frost protection before the footprint rises anywhere near the level of the transport costs for out of season veg. Of course green sources of heat ane electricity could be used. I guess that makes the cheap price of transport fuels the biggest issue.

Re: Let's use the Gulf Stream to increase UK food production
Posted By EC017270 1 June 10, 2010 11:28:59 AM

As a commercial vegetable grower I have to applaud Adam's comments. We farm on the Essex coast, benefiting (at times) from the reduced number of frosts. Incidentally the higher light levels are also an advantage worth mentioning. The industry would be quick to grow more vegetables and salads if returns from the supermarkets made it viable, at the moment its not worth it financially. We justifiably talk of a real wage, we also need to talk about a real value for our food. Supermarkets focus on high margins to satisfy shareholder's demand for high dividends. As long as such a high percentage of retail prices is effectively leaving the food supply chain, we will be stuck in the current situation. A final word of caution on poly tunnels; a study this year showed the carbon footprint of tunnel grown strawberries is larger than field grown despite the fact that tunnel grown allows pesticide free production. Before we claim that tunnel grown is best we need to make sure the sums back us up, even if our instinct tells us we are doing the right thing.

Re: Let's use the Gulf Stream to increase UK food production
Posted By Byng 1 June 10, 2010 12:02:52 PM

Adam York is right that local organic food production will become a necessity as oil prices rise. He is also right to suggest that the UK needs to anticipate the economic necessity with policy measures that get us off to a head start. The tricky bit will be to nuance the support so as not to overstimulate production before the market is ready for it.

Re: Let's use the Gulf Stream to increase UK food production
Posted By sillofthedoor 1 June 17, 2010 11:44:23 AM

All very well, but isn't it part of climate change expectations that the gulf stream will fail at some point, causing a drop in local temperatures?

Re: Let's use the Gulf Stream to increase UK food production
Posted By AdamYork 1 June 26, 2010 09:29:40 AM

Currently some volume of comment on the Riverford Farm site over use of tunnels to grow Strawberies.This follows Guy Watson's zeal to attempt outdoor on big ridges with well spaced plants,with variable results and too much waste.The success of Haygrove in the UK and significant extension of the Strawbery season is a good thing.This because imports were directly replaced,crop wastage was much lower(wet fruit usually lost)and the use of fungicide to tangle with damp and mould issues much reduced.Having sold Riverford Strawberries at Unicorn the taste was variable and sugars too low too often. Polytunnels are made of steel that can be used for several hundred years if need be or recycled without enormous energy use.The plastic many Riverford bloggers comment on but worth noting that quite a lot of plastics collections from farms for recycling already take place.The energy load form the plastic is relatively low.As with all materials we need to use them frugally and use durable design.Tunnels represent pragramatism in the face of a big population,lots of nutrients produced using little energy.

credit card security
Posted By LeareAnaefavy 1 August 13, 2011 10:54:58 AM

http://infraud.cc?carders-forum-fraud http://infraud.cc?selling-dumps
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image
 
 

Members





Follow the Ecologist