The Ecologist

 
With damming of the Tapajos river, a whole world of biodiversity, beauty and indigenous cultures will be destroyed forever. Photo: Canoe on the Tapajos by Clairex (CC BY-NC-SA).
With damming of the Tapajos river, a whole world of biodiversity, beauty and indigenous cultures will be destroyed forever. Photo: Canoe on the Tapajos by Clairex (CC BY-NC-SA).
More articles about
Related Articles

European companies line up to bid for Amazon megadam

Zachary Davies Boren / Greenpeace Energydesk

13th April 2016

Disregarding revelations of systemic political corruption in Brazil's hydropower sector, President Dilma Rousseff is ploughing ahead with a cascade of giant dams on the mighty Tapajos river. Among the companies touting to win huge construction contracts are France's EDF and Engie, and Germany's Voith and Siemens - in a consortium led by Brazil's Electrobras, which stands accused of high-level corruption over four other dam projects.

It is perhaps surprising that, in spite of the stink of corruption around Brazil's energy sector and the risks the dam poses to native peoples and the environment, European energy companies are still looking to get involved.

Major European energy companies are set to build and run the controversial mega-dam project planned for the Tapajos river in the heart of the Amazon.

This comes as a senior construction official has implicated the nearby Belo Monte dam in the massive corruption scandal that has engulfed President Dilma Rousseff and the country's most powerful political figures.

Otávio Marques de Azevedo, former president of the Brazilian construction company Andrade Gutierrez, told investigators that the Belo Monte dam was used to generate donations of 150m reais ($41.4m) to the ruling coalition. Dozens of other projects were also corruptly used to generate funds for political parties, he testified in a plea bargain.

The Brazilian government is aggressively promoting the development of an enormous hydropower complex on the Amazonian waterway despite fears that it would cause mass deforestation and flooding that would devastate indigenous communities and the wildlife.

French utilities EDF and Engie are members of a study group of companies who may bid to win contracts for the largest dam in the initiative - the São Luiz do Tapajós project. The study group also involves Brazilian firms linked to the ongoing corruption investigation.

Italian energy company Enel quit the group earlier this year, claiming the dam jarred with a fresh set of priorities introduced by new, environmentally friendly management.

A joint venture between German firms Siemens and Voith, though not part of the construction consortia, is thought likely to manufacture the turbines used at the dam and to be an otherwise key player in the supply chain.

Meanwhile China Three Gorges, the controversial company behind the enormous dam that bears its name, is also fishing for contracts, but - seeing as it's not part of the favoured group - it may not actually get the job.

Most of the rest of the firms likely to be involved in the Tapajos hydro scheme are Brazilian, led by state-owned Electrobras.

Why Tapajos matters

At 800km, the Tapajos is the fifth largest tributary of the Amazon River, supporting over 14,500 indigenous peoples as well as an inestimable amount of flora and fauna.

By far the largest of the several dams planned for the river, the São Luiz do Tapajós dam (SLT) is set to stand 53 metres high and 7.6km wide, and will have an installed capacity of 8,000MW.

To get a sense of the environmental impacts of a dam this size, simply cast your eyes east to Belo Monte, where the world's third largest hydro project is currently under construction. The project has led to reports of huge amounts of forest burned and felled, and an increased trade in illegal timber, on top of the deforestation caused by the dam itself.

The Tapajos initiative could risk the diverse animal and plant life in region, whilst indigenous peoples, most prominently the Munduruku, will see some of their sacred lands flooded.

Following the Belo Monte corruption revelations Danicley Aguiar, Amazon campaigner for Greenpeace Brazil, said the report highlighted the need to halt the planned cascade of dams on the Tapajós river:

"Andrade Gutierrez has exposed one of the worst-kept secrets in Brazil, that our infrastructure projects are riddled with corruption, including the major dams in Amazonia. The first question which needs answering is why the Brazilian government insists on building mega-dams instead of investing in more efficient and less destructive options like solar and wind power, which are capable of answering the Brazilian demand for energy."

Here come the Europeans

Companies and groups are right now readying bids for contracts to be issued via an auction run by Brazil's power regulator. So far two major prospective bidders have emerged - both with ties to the Brazilian state-owned electricity company Electrobras.

The first is an eight-company consortia called Grupo de Estudos, which includes Engie and Électricité de France (EDF), two of the largest energy companies in Europe. The consortium, led by Eletrobras, also includes Eletronorte (a subsidiary of Eletrobras), Camargo Corrêa, Cemig, Copel, and Neoenergia.

Though it has yet to formally announce its intention to bid for contract, the group has already submitted an Environmental Impact Assessment - plus it's name is a dead giveaway.

It is perhaps surprising that, in spite of the stink of corruption around Brazil's energy sector and the risks the dam poses to native peoples and the environment, European energy companies are still looking to get involved. It didn't gel for Italian company Enel, who quit the consortia this year in the latest sign of its crisis of conscience.

Engie have been operating in Brazil for years already, with subsidiary Tractebel Energia the country's largest independent energy producer (it runs 6% of Brazil's installed generation capacity).

EDF, who in Hinkley Point nuclear plant is already embroiled in international controversy over a massive energy infrastructure project, has explicitly said it will not "tolerate any violation of human rights", is committed to "transparency and dialogue" and considers protecting biodiversity as a "group priority".

In a statement given to Energydesk, EDF said it has yet to take an investment decision on the Tapajos dam, and "is still checking that social and environmental requirements, a major concern for the Group, are carefully met".

This isn't to suggest the only western giants associated with the Tapajos initiative are part of this study group, far from it. There's also Voith Hydro, a joint venture between German firms Voith and Siemens.

This collaboration, which supplies turbines and generators, has been working on the troubled Belo Monte dam nearby, providing four turbines, four generators, electrical and mechanical auxiliaries, the automation system and the complete engineering services for the project.

US enterprise General Electric, via its recently acquired Alstom subsidiary, hasn't ruled out getting in on the Tapajos business either.

We have reached out to these firms for comment and will update the piece if and when it is provided.

China wants to get involved

Okay, so that's what's behind door number 1. Door number 2, which is rather less likely to be opened, finds the Chinese state and another Electrobras subsidiary with a joint bid. In 2014 the Brazilian company Furnas partnered with China Three Gorges (CTG) to carry out a feasibility study on the SLT megadam.

Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff were at the signing ceremony, which marked - along with the Hinkley nuclear project - a new strategy from Beijing: export its capital expenditure energy infrastructure.

CTG, infamous for the mass displacement caused by the dam it built on the Yangtze River in China, is now looking west to branch out its business, with a special eye on the Brazilian market.

It recently acquired a 30-year concession to operate two hydropower plants in Brazil, the Jupiá and Ilha Solteira dams.

Brazil's corruption scandal

At the centre of both prospective bids is Electrobras, the second largest energy company in Brazil. Yes, Electrobras is state-owned and therefore tied to in some degree the corruption crisis that threatens to take down the Rousseff administration.

The company is facing two class action lawsuits in the US, one of which alleges that senior executives and subsidiaries profited from bribery and money associated with major projects, including the Belo Monte, Jiaru, Santo Antonio and Teles Pires dams.

This lawsuit, led by the municipal corporation of Providence, Rhode Island on behalf of anyone who acquired shares in Electrobras between 2010 and 2015, was born out of the wider corruption scandal which originated with Petrobras, the country's other major state-owned energy company.

Recently the Belo Monte dam has become a focus on the investigation, with just last month Senator Delcídio do Amaral admitting $9 million had been siphoned off from the project to fund election campaigns.

He added that the corruption around Belo Monte extended to exerting political pressure to ensure contracts were awarded to companies such as IMPSA, Siemens and Alstom.

 


 

Zachary Davies Boren is an environment journalist writing for Greenpeace Energydesk, the Press Association, The Telegraph, The Independent, Huffington Post, IBTimes, Yahoo, Chicago Tribune and other media.

This article was originally published on Greenpeace Energydesk.

 

Previous Articles...

ECOLOGIST COOKIES

Using this website means you agree to us using simple cookies.

More information here...

 

FOLLOW
THE ECOLOGIST