The Ecologist

More articles about
Related Articles

Waste management proves a profitable business

Martin O'Brien

7th August, 2008

Martin O'Brien investigates how waste management has become a lucrative business.

Not everything that Dick predicted has come to pass, but, as with all good science fiction, the most illuminating parts of Dick’s story concern his reflections on the present rather than the accuracy of his divinations. In Dick’s world of 2012, waste management is a central, rather than peripheral, dimension of urban and rural existence; something that affects every individual on the planet in the most direct and immediate way imaginable. In the world of 2008, this is already a reality.

Of course, there are different ways in which Dick’s waste management prophecy might have played out. ‘Ownership’ of waste management might have been placed with its producers; with local or central government; regions or communities; with families or individuals; with co-operatives. The economic consequences of waste management might have been shared on principles of social equity, so that the poorest constituencies do not face the highest costs. The technological and operational characteristics of waste management might have been devised to emphasise useful employment, local control, community renewal and/or energy and resource efficiency.

What we have, in fact, are massive contracts with multinational conglomerates that tie waste management to private sector profits for decades – 25 years being the contractual norm. By the early 2000s, three-quarters of all refuse collection contracts were held by just four companies: Onyx, Sita, Serviceteam and Cleanaway. Six more held the remaining quarter.

The top four have global turnovers measured in billions of pounds, while the remainder manage turnovers of mere hundreds of millions. These contractual arrangements do indeed confer political responsibility for waste management on Local Authorities (LAs), but without any direct operational control. Instead, those authorities are left trailing in the wake of private sector responses to national and transnational regulatory arrangements.

It is private sector responses to policies (on which they have already lobbied vigorously) that determine what is and is not allowed to happen to your waste. If you do not like the political make-up of your local council you can vote them out of office within four or five years. If you do not like the operational characteristics of the conglomerate that deals with your waste, that’s just tough. You will have to wait for 25 years or more until the council makes another choice without any reference to your preferences; or, more likely, until some other multinational conglomerate you don’t like takes over from the one you currently don’t like.

Some people think of this situation as an instance of the ‘privatisation’ of public functions, but we should be careful about the terminology. Privatisation, to be sure, is certainly happening, but in relation to the giant contracts with conglomerates it is more accurate to say that waste management is being subjected to processes of marketisation, and waste itself to commodification.

The direction of waste management policy since the early 1990s has been to open up markets for municipal wastes; to make those wastes into tradeable, exploitable, profitable commodities. Even the titles of consultations and draft strategy documents give the game away with more or less commendable clarity: ‘Making Waste Work’ (1995), ‘Less Waste, More Value’ (1998), and the marvellously cryptic ‘A Way With Waste’ (1999) all proposed to ‘inform’ consumers, reach ‘voluntary agreements’ with producers and retailers, and ‘incentivise’ producers, consumers and disposers.

Rhetoric aside, none of them promised (or showed how) to prevent waste from arising. Indeed, their aim and purpose was quite different: not to prevent or reduce waste in the first place but to organise its profitability in an economy of rubbish values.

In order to marketise waste it has been necessary to develop a bewildering array of instruments, rules, regulations, stipulations, subsidies, permissions and exemptions. From the Local Government Act of 1988, with its extension of compulsory competitive tendering from infrastructure projects to public services (and exemption clauses enabling LAs to hold equity in public service ventures), through the waste disposal ‘companies’ provisions of the 1990 Environmental Protection Act, to the ‘best value’ requirements of the 1999 Local Government Act, the legislative carousel has consistently spun on the axis of markets, profits and contracts, rather than accountability, involvement and control.

In turn, the new milieu of waste management has seen the emergence of amazingly complicated trading and fiscal arrangements for ensuring that the cash flows from the public streets to the corporate elites – such as the packaging reclamation notes, regional price ‘weights’ to compensate for ‘rubbish miles’ and – my personal favourite – the ‘Lipworth Modified Converter Levy’ devised to raise funds from the waste-packaging chain.

None of these has anything to do with ‘privatisation’ as commonly understood, the wholesale transfer of public services to private hands . They are all about the intensely political process of turning waste management into a commodities market rather than an environmental responsibility. In order to privatise anything you first have to create a market in which private interests can predominate over public ones, and this is what is happening to our rubbish.

In these circumstances, if the market says your electronic waste can release profits by being shipped to India then shipped to India it will be. If the market says your ‘recycled’ glass can release profits by being crushed and sold as fish-tank bedding then crushed and sold as fish-tank bedding it will be. If the market says that you – a private individual in a private household – must do the (unremunerated) work of sifting, sorting, storing and delivering waste commodities for global corporations to exploit then this is what you will do.

Remember, though, that when the market says there is no more profit to be had out of any of these things, your electronic waste and glass will be dumped and your paper buried or burned. You have no say in the details of the decades-long contracts and esoteric political arrangements that make the private interests of global conglomerates predominate over the public interests of your local community.

Perhaps it’s time for a different arrangement, one that puts us as citizens – not consumers or disposers – at the heart of any future waste management policy. In 1905, in the London Borough of Hackney alone, some 5,000 to 6,000 households every week refused to hand over their waste for collection precisely because of a suspicion that others were profiting from the valuable resources contained in their dustbins.

We ought to learn at least this lesson from our forebears: the marketisation of waste means that commercial organisations have a vested interest not only in the continued production of detritus, but also in exploiting the sorting, sifting and storing labours that householders are increasingly compelled to provide for free by the legal regime surrounding the commodity of waste.

Martin O’Brien is a sociologist and criminologist at the University of Central Lancashire, and author of A Crisis of Waste? Understanding the Rubbish Society

This article first appeared in the Ecologist September 2008


Previous Articles...

Users Comments

Re: Waste management proves a profitable business
Posted By ofmttmwz38 1 October 31, 2015 11:37:49 PM

EexJmr [url=]cheap watches men[/url] EozLmr [url=]imitation rolex watches[/url] WkxJgo [url=]discount watch store[/url] GwqKui [url=]discount watches online[/url] ZbpVnd [url=]swiss replica watches[/url] HbeEuu [url=]swiss replica rolex watches[/url] LkmRzc [url=]fake rolex[/url] KlwJwy [url=]fake rolex watches for men[/url] OezTfn [url=]rolex replica watches sale[/url] DorFuh [url=]rolex watches replica[/url] EsjAwj [url=]calvin klein outlet online[/url] GpxEjn [url=]calvin klein outlet stores[/url] ApfSlt [url=]calvin klein underwear[/url] CdxTqy [url=]calvin klein underwear sale[/url] VpzBxi [url=]calvin klein underwear women[/url] LwzXve [url=]calvin klein underwear for women[/url] VwyPuk [url=]calvin klein men[/url] PuzRpx [url=]men calvin klein[/url] IduIju [url=]calvin klein men[/url] RbgNua [url=]men calvin klein[/url] JlhEvb [url=]christian louboutin[/url] VdjQyi [url=]canada goose jacket[/url] IgmVlb [url=]louis vuitton online shop[/url] JjzJba [url=]michael kors handbags[/url] AhhDoa [url=]michael kors outlet[/url] BktAyt [url=]wholesale nfl jerseys[/url] BltNpw [url=]canada goose outlet[/url] OepDsf [url=]michael kors outlet[/url] ZfwQwk [url=]canada goose men[/url] XvfHwg [url=]cheap canada goose[/url] CjqKgy [url=]canada goose sale[/url] DghWtq [url=]canada goose sale[/url] OvhAzj [url=]cheap canada goose[/url] ImoYwh [url=]canada goose coats[/url] BpoQge [url=]coast dress sale[/url] LkoLym [url=]oakley outlet[/url] JnhRfr [url=]barbour black friday deals[/url]

Re: Waste management proves a profitable business
Posted By ofmttmwz38 1 November 15, 2015 06:28:15 PM

OjqYkd [url=]cheap rolex watches[/url] MooWzu [url=]imitation rolex watches[/url] GhdEdi [url=]discount watch store[/url] DfpSaw [url=]discount watches online[/url] NdzPnf [url=]swiss replica watches[/url] SelUet [url=]swiss replica rolex watches[/url] YxoGte [url=]fake rolex watches[/url] LhdMkv [url=]fake rolex watches for sale[/url] PhqNlc [url=]rolex replica watches sale[/url] AsrKpm [url=]rolex watches replica[/url] OvoWsf [url=]calvin klein outlet online[/url] DfjUfi [url=]calvin klein underwear sale[/url] KaeGfz [url=]calvin klein outlet online[/url] DbvLog [url=]calvin klein underwear outlet[/url] CjqRef [url=]calvin klein women underwear[/url] UavYom [url=]calvin klein womens underwear[/url] TadRmh [url=]calvin klein men[/url] DvaXqw [url=]men calvin klein[/url] ZocNpm [url=]calvin klein underwear men[/url] QcoSxh [url=]mens calvin klein underwear[/url] FspCgf [url=]christian louboutin sale[/url] XmzXnx [url=]canada goose parka[/url] TnpBih [url=]louis vuitton outlet[/url] DueZwt [url=]michael kors outlet store[/url] LipJbt [url=]michael kors bags on sale[/url] QgyNyt [url=]cheap jerseys[/url] OcdKmk [url=]canada goose sale[/url] NayNrq [url=]michael kors outlet[/url] JiiKsn [url=]women canada goose jackets[/url] EibYph [url=]cheap canada goose[/url] PfcFjz [url=]canada goose coats[/url] EudDqx [url=]canada goose sale[/url] UghMvo [url=]canada goose parka sale[/url] RwiXvy [url=]canada goose sale[/url] LjvVlz [url=]karen millen coats[/url] HsuKee [url=]ray ban sunglasses outlet[/url] HpeTwy [url=]barbour outlet[/url]

mac cosmetics reviews mac cosmetics us site
Posted By ralphbsinqh 1 November 15, 2016 09:05:37 AM

[url=]kylie eyeshadow[/url] online cheap shop cosmetics for sale online discount designer makeup mac make up cheap,what stores sell mac makeup discount cosmetics uk mac brush sets ukfree shippinf.

cheap mac makeup for sale mac online cosmetics
Posted By macmakeupkm 1 November 16, 2016 01:49:48 PM

[url=]cheap kylie makeup[/url] discount websites cheap quality cosmetics cheap makeup for sale online sale mac cosmetics,mac cosmetics online coupon code mac cosmetics wholesale free shipping mac makeup discounts sites offering free shipping prime shipping.

where can i buy mac makeup where can i buy mac makeup products
Posted By macmakeupax 1 November 17, 2016 05:18:21 PM

[url=]kylie birthday lip[/url] low price online shopping site best affordable makeup discontinued makeup mac cosmetics eyeshadow,mac makeup cyber monday mac cosmetics price range cheap mac makeup online shoppingcheck order online free shipping.

mac beauty products wholesale authentic mac cosmetics wholesale
Posted By makeupsalekv 1 November 18, 2016 03:02:05 PM

[url=]Lime Crime Venus Eyeshadow[/url] best discount stores online bargain beauty productsacw makeup,.

cheap mac cosmetics pro mac makeup wholesalers uk
Posted By makeupsynzb 1 November 22, 2016 07:11:35 AM

[url=]kylie birthday lip kit mini[/url] cheap makeup websites discount foundation makeup makeup discounts online outlet mac makeup,mac makeup coupons mac makeup gift sets uk buy mac cosmetics cheap online sites with free 2 day shipping free shipping coupon.

discounts on mac makeup buy mac makeup cheap
Posted By cosmeticsxxw 1 November 22, 2016 10:55:16 AM

[url=]the bronze palette eyeshadow kit[/url] makeup sale where to buy cheap cosmetics online makeup online sale mac sales makeup,mac cosmetics coupon code 10 off cheap wholesale mac makeup wholesale mac cosmetics outlet deals free shipping free international shipping.

shop mac makeup cheap mac cosmetics with free shipping
Posted By makeupusady 1 November 24, 2016 04:39:17 PM

[url=]Lime Crime Venus Palette[/url] clothes outlets online makeup artist cosmetics online uk makeup supplies wholesale, where sells mac makeup wholesale makeup for resale.

authentic mac makeup cheap mac makeup sets
Posted By ralphbsinqh 1 November 30, 2016 03:23:11 AM

[url=]anastasia cosmetics singapore[/url] mens outlet stores online cheap quality makeup cheapest store to buy makeup wholesale mac makeup uk,mac lipstick coupons mac professional makeup kits uk wholesale lipstick ukelectronics free shipping.

makeup online outlet mac cosmetics mac pro
Posted By macmakeupkm 1 December 1, 2016 08:27:52 AM

[url=]Lime Crime Lip Gloss Red Velvet[/url] discount clothes shopping online discount makeup free shipping benefit makeup sale wholesale mac brushes,mac make up wholesale mac makeup products online mac makeup website ukonline shopping 1 day delivery.

sale mac cosmetics mac makeup discount uk
Posted By macmakeupax 1 December 2, 2016 05:53:19 AM

[url=]Lime Crime Lip Gloss Matte[/url] bargain shopping online cheap online makeup shopping buy online makeup buy cosmetics wholesale,mac makeup cheap online mac makeup sales uk mac cosmetics discountsstores that have free shipping.

mac makeup wholesale free shipping authentic mac makeup sale
Posted By makeupsalekv 1 December 2, 2016 10:14:30 PM

[url=]cosmetics wholesale[/url] all cosmetics cosmetic online shop cheap makeup set buy makeup cheap,makeup wholesale mac discount high end makeup uk where to buy mac makeup wholesalefree shipping over.

mac cosmetic deals mac makeup america
Posted By makeupsynzb 1 December 5, 2016 03:17:20 PM

[url=]kylie makeup products[/url] cheapest price online shopping discount cosmetic outlet makeup online store makeup wholesale free shipping,maccosmetics sale mac cosmetics mac cosmetics online europefree shipping to usa.

professional cosmetics wholesale mac makeup pro uk
Posted By cosmeticsxxw 1 December 5, 2016 05:33:59 PM

[url=]I Have Two Moods Makeup[/url] shopping cheap online best cheap makeup products online discount beauty products designer makeup sale,buy mac cosmetics online cheap outlet makeup cheapest mac cosmetics productfree shipping company.

designer makeup on sale mac store online makeup
Posted By makeupusady 1 December 6, 2016 09:06:01 PM

[url=]the bronze palette[/url] good cheap online stores cheap makeup brushes free shipping cheap high quality makeup which stores sell mac makeup,cheap make up discount designer makeup mac makeup kitsfee shipping.
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image


Using this website means you agree to us using simple cookies.

More information here...




Help us keep the Ecologist platform going

Since 2012, the Ecologist has been owned and published by a small UK-based charity called the Resurgence Trust. We work hard to support the kind of independent journalism and comment that we know Ecologist readers enjoy but we need your help to keep going. We do all this on a very small budget with a very small editorial team and so joining the Trust or making a donation will show us you value our work and support the platform which is currently offered as a free service.

Join The Resurgence TrustDonate to support the Resurgence Trust