Waste management proves a profitable business
7th August, 2008
Martin O'Brien investigates how waste management has become a lucrative business.
Not everything that Dick predicted has come to pass, but, as with all good science fiction, the most illuminating parts of Dick’s story concern his reflections on the present rather than the accuracy of his divinations. In Dick’s world of 2012, waste management is a central, rather than peripheral, dimension of urban and rural existence; something that affects every individual on the planet in the most direct and immediate way imaginable. In the world of 2008, this is already a reality.
Of course, there are different ways in which Dick’s waste management prophecy might have played out. ‘Ownership’ of waste management might have been placed with its producers; with local or central government; regions or communities; with families or individuals; with co-operatives. The economic consequences of waste management might have been shared on principles of social equity, so that the poorest constituencies do not face the highest costs. The technological and operational characteristics of waste management might have been devised to emphasise useful employment, local control, community renewal and/or energy and resource efficiency.
What we have, in fact, are massive contracts with multinational conglomerates that tie waste management to private sector profits for decades – 25 years being the contractual norm. By the early 2000s, three-quarters of all refuse collection contracts were held by just four companies: Onyx, Sita, Serviceteam and Cleanaway. Six more held the remaining quarter.
The top four have global turnovers measured in billions of pounds, while the remainder manage turnovers of mere hundreds of millions. These contractual arrangements do indeed confer political responsibility for waste management on Local Authorities (LAs), but without any direct operational control. Instead, those authorities are left trailing in the wake of private sector responses to national and transnational regulatory arrangements.
It is private sector responses to policies (on which they have already lobbied vigorously) that determine what is and is not allowed to happen to your waste. If you do not like the political make-up of your local council you can vote them out of office within four or five years. If you do not like the operational characteristics of the conglomerate that deals with your waste, that’s just tough. You will have to wait for 25 years or more until the council makes another choice without any reference to your preferences; or, more likely, until some other multinational conglomerate you don’t like takes over from the one you currently don’t like.
Some people think of this situation as an instance of the ‘privatisation’ of public functions, but we should be careful about the terminology. Privatisation, to be sure, is certainly happening, but in relation to the giant contracts with conglomerates it is more accurate to say that waste management is being subjected to processes of marketisation, and waste itself to commodification.
The direction of waste management policy since the early 1990s has been to open up markets for municipal wastes; to make those wastes into tradeable, exploitable, profitable commodities. Even the titles of consultations and draft strategy documents give the game away with more or less commendable clarity: ‘Making Waste Work’ (1995), ‘Less Waste, More Value’ (1998), and the marvellously cryptic ‘A Way With Waste’ (1999) all proposed to ‘inform’ consumers, reach ‘voluntary agreements’ with producers and retailers, and ‘incentivise’ producers, consumers and disposers.
Rhetoric aside, none of them promised (or showed how) to prevent waste from arising. Indeed, their aim and purpose was quite different: not to prevent or reduce waste in the first place but to organise its profitability in an economy of rubbish values.
In order to marketise waste it has been necessary to develop a bewildering array of instruments, rules, regulations, stipulations, subsidies, permissions and exemptions. From the Local Government Act of 1988, with its extension of compulsory competitive tendering from infrastructure projects to public services (and exemption clauses enabling LAs to hold equity in public service ventures), through the waste disposal ‘companies’ provisions of the 1990 Environmental Protection Act, to the ‘best value’ requirements of the 1999 Local Government Act, the legislative carousel has consistently spun on the axis of markets, profits and contracts, rather than accountability, involvement and control.
In turn, the new milieu of waste management has seen the emergence of amazingly complicated trading and fiscal arrangements for ensuring that the cash flows from the public streets to the corporate elites – such as the packaging reclamation notes, regional price ‘weights’ to compensate for ‘rubbish miles’ and – my personal favourite – the ‘Lipworth Modified Converter Levy’ devised to raise funds from the waste-packaging chain.
None of these has anything to do with ‘privatisation’ as commonly understood, the wholesale transfer of public services to private hands . They are all about the intensely political process of turning waste management into a commodities market rather than an environmental responsibility. In order to privatise anything you first have to create a market in which private interests can predominate over public ones, and this is what is happening to our rubbish.
In these circumstances, if the market says your electronic waste can release profits by being shipped to India then shipped to India it will be. If the market says your ‘recycled’ glass can release profits by being crushed and sold as fish-tank bedding then crushed and sold as fish-tank bedding it will be. If the market says that you – a private individual in a private household – must do the (unremunerated) work of sifting, sorting, storing and delivering waste commodities for global corporations to exploit then this is what you will do.
Remember, though, that when the market says there is no more profit to be had out of any of these things, your electronic waste and glass will be dumped and your paper buried or burned. You have no say in the details of the decades-long contracts and esoteric political arrangements that make the private interests of global conglomerates predominate over the public interests of your local community.
Perhaps it’s time for a different arrangement, one that puts us as citizens – not consumers or disposers – at the heart of any future waste management policy. In 1905, in the London Borough of Hackney alone, some 5,000 to 6,000 households every week refused to hand over their waste for collection precisely because of a suspicion that others were profiting from the valuable resources contained in their dustbins.
We ought to learn at least this lesson from our forebears: the marketisation of waste means that commercial organisations have a vested interest not only in the continued production of detritus, but also in exploiting the sorting, sifting and storing labours that householders are increasingly compelled to provide for free by the legal regime surrounding the commodity of waste.
Martin O’Brien is a sociologist and criminologist at the University of Central Lancashire, and author of A Crisis of Waste? Understanding the Rubbish Society
This article first appeared in the Ecologist September 2008
Assoribeare soaffolla Bopsvursosy Getledamoma nsiudr Air max Running Shoes eqfvmr Air Max Running Shoes lzypsf Nike air Max 36 running Shoes pegqic http://airmaxrunningshoes.org xtrzrr new nike running shoes qnddnl newest nike running shoes nifshr new Nike running shoe rzabqp http://newnikerunningshoes.org pgonhv nike Running trainers men xqnbsl nike running trainers wyonnk Nike Running Trainers ieatck http://nikerunningtrainersonline.com sjukek Air max Red rawksq air max 24 7 red zhzuab air Max 95 red vnrzzf http://airmaxred.org dofepo nike air max kids drefmq Kids air Max 95 xhnmcd Nike Air Max Kids mgxgls http://nikeairmaxkids.org xtmzfc Nike Air Max Women ghucco nike Air max 9 Women yzerdo nike air max women kdywii http://nike-air-maxwomen.com ygzhcl black nike blazers for women nywzpz nike blazers black opeysf nike Blazer black brfcyr http://nikeblackblazersonline.com bnyyjn Grey nike Blazers pszikt nike blazer grey ubsdsv Grey nike Blazers uxtfce http://nikegreyblazers.com esqjau christian louboutin london store wcecvi christian louboutin london sxpcpp christian louboutin london wipnyn http://christiannlouboutinlondon.com ntpqwj Cheap Air Max 24 7 kkpvga cheap Air max 24 7 aivjjv Cheap air Max 24 7 urgbwh http://cheapairmax247.org wtsvpm Air max 95 Orange ljvcdr Air max Orange xppriv air Max 95 orange ttjfux http://airmaxorange.org vszddw Nike Barefoot Running qqqbaj nike Barefoot running dterqv Nike Barefoot Running aujgzw http://nikebarefootrunningshoes.org kkyolb Nike Air Max 9 Australia gplfds Nike Air Max 9 Australia vdrkla Nike Air Max 9 xqbsqm http://nikeairmax90australia.org hwshdd Air yeezy For Sale leqchv air yeezy for sale hmpkzy nike air yeezy for sale azcgcx http://nikeairyeezyforsale.org wseosu women nike blazers gbzszh women Nike blazers fxjuos Nike blazer Women tlcfzm http://nikeblazersforwomen.com cluvyr Nike Blazers For Men hjhxwp cheap nike blazers for men lsxlnr Cheap Nike Blazers For Men lgsqhh http://nikeblazersformen.com omhjkb mens Nike air max 9 zvaico mens Nike air max nymhie nike Air max 95 Mens ockclo http://mensnikeairmax.org lizwss Nike Blazer Vintage High nlytom Nike Blazer Vintage High hdtull Nike Blazer Mid Vintage tmwkvt http://nikevintageblazer.com pkgdtp louboutin men qpkzzq Christian Louboutin Mens Shoes elthse Christian Louboutin Mens kgywgd http://christianllouboutinmens.com bxvqut Fake Air Max 9 lhdcsj Fake air Max 9 npjxbc Fake air Max 9 jrwgtu http://fakenikeairmax.org ptkkdp Air Max Online Shop wejltt nike Air max shop Online wlgzab nike air max shop online nevoht http://air-maxonline.com htigov Air max Premium keljbl nike air max 9 premium qzwuda nike Air max premium uezvmv http://nikeairmaxpremium.org tsjhod new nike air max lkpjmz new air max xkjbrh new Air max 95 rwitpu http://new-nikeairmax.org qmmxkm Nike Huarache Basketball Shoes bzrmet Nike air Max Basketball shoes szfbgm nike air max basketball kvkitw http://nikeairmaxbasketball.org yagsxz air max sale myasph Air max 95 For sale fzcrfy Air max 95 For sale agbgqo http://air-maxsale.org kmiuon Louboutin outlet Uk reivaf louboutin outlet uk ehkkdq louboutin outlet uk mwsgtr http://christianllouboutinoutletuk.com ajmjrb Baby air Max ggaxff Nike air Max Baby orjtub Baby air Max atbooc http://babynikeairmax.org bpvlan buy Nike blazers oifpzn where can i buy nike blazers ayvbno buy nike blazers abwqpt http://buynikeblazers.org npamki white nike blazers wjrrpa White nike Blazers aljczp White Nike Blazers flhqjl http://nikeblazerswhite.com yclppv red bottom shoes djlxgp Red Bottom Shoes kgqmrn Red Bottom Heels xgdamy http://redbbottom-shoes.com qfmabb Nike Air Max Hyperize vqbrnl air Max hyperize yezjit nike Hyperize air max iufrou http://nikeairmaxhyperize.org voayvw Discount nike Air Max ejzvgu Discount Air Max fxarhg discount Air max shoes arciiw http://discounttairmax.com wfxncb nike Mid blazer qwukdg nike Blazers mid bnnbxu Nike blazer Mid Vintage iwwiox http://nikemidblazer.org alqcew Nike Blazer Shoes feuqzd Nike blazer Shoes bnpnhy nike blazer shoes uapaoq http://nikeblazershoesoutlet.com gkwody nike air structure triax etzyqc Nike Air Structure Triax ttbgzz Nike Air Structure Triax 91 hhiczb http://nikestructuretriax.org wsepjm Nike Flex Running Shoes yhdrkx nike flex 214 mens running shoes munirz Nike flex Experience Ladies running Shoes xgdtpf http://nikeflexrunningshoes.com zqkojc Air Max Black qgbaxg nike Air yeezy black Pink ijrwla nike Air yeezy black Pink zegkzn http://airmax-black.org bjmcii nike Air max limited fpbkvg Air Max Limited jfxbrk Air max Limited iqtfdo http://nikeairmaxlimitededition.org kznlqb nike running shorts women dibnls nike running shorts women qvgjqr Nike Running Shorts gcejrd http://nikerunningshortssale.com yviuoi Nike Air Max Light fhneac Nike Air Max Light mygisw Air max Light shmguw http://nike-airmax-light.com vsvyyz Nike Zoom Victory Running Spikes zrxneq Nike Zoom Victory Running Spikes iiobeg Nike Running Spikes vjfris http://nikerunningspikes.org utfadn Nike Running Store iilnei nike store running shoes dvaota nike running shoes store cdjtfk http://nikerunningstore.org sccwdf nike blazer suede canugz Nike blazer Hi Suede vintage sfgjmq nike blazer hi suede vintage ezeuec http://nikeblazersuede.org fwvusj nike Running shoes for Women tysllt nike womens running shoes sjpfct nike womens running shoes hsbiyk http://bestnikerunningshoes.org ehmsyh Air max Gold hlgmtu air max gold dqxkbn Gold Air Max 97 jvpeiw http://airmaxgold.org ssspyr Nike Running Shorts Sale ombmra nike running shoes on sale lktvca Nike Running Shoes On Sale xonbbx http://nikerunningshoessale.org bpkaok christian Louboutin stockists vbmimc christian Louboutin uk stockists zyzrbn Christian louboutin Uk Stockists nzvuls http://christianllouboutinukstockists.com cqopto Nike lunar Forever Ladies running Shoes sjdomj Nike lunar Forever Ladies running Shoes eeuxuc ladies Nike running shoes lzwnqw http://nikeladiesrunningshoes.com yktutg nike air max 9 nfihtz Nike air Max Shop prknxq Nike air Max 1 gisyrc http://nike-airmaxshop.org oohgkw Nike Trail Running fstltp Nike trail Running Shoes women gsszux Nike Trail Running Shoes For Men cefvev http://niketrailrunningshoes.net kvaqga Air max Griffey 1 oijnrh Griffey air Max 1 rpirth Air Max Griffey 1 sfshzg http://airmaxxgriffey.com rhivtu nike air max turbulence vhqxww air max turbulence 16 saszwv air Max turbulence 16 rvfcbo http://nike-airmaxturbulence.org yccqcz nike air max girls bqqvpy nike Air max girls ktmnde nike Air max girls cfmssr http://nikeairmaxgirls.org jwpsxe Nike discount Running Shoes vcjrml discount Nike running shoes iljvxa Nike discount Running Shoes bthadz http://discountnikerunningshoes.org umdavs Nike air Max 9 infrared qonsfb Nike air Max 9 women hvriue nike Air max 9 Women ldelaa http://nike-air-max90.org nvltaj Nike Blazer Sale dxjqxh Nike Blazers On Sale zdlpzr nike blazer sale wbrrmv http://nikeblazersforsale.org lvyfnt Air max Infrared dgkomb nike Air max infrared bzzony nike air max 9 infrared ehmtat http://airmaxinfrared.org iatzuh nike mens running shoes fxoanp Nike running Shoes Men awnlth Nike running Shoes For men oqnwsu http://mensnikerunningshoes.com fxjebl nike Air max cheap piuirj Nike Air Max Cheap wxgbpg Nike Air Max 9 Cheap afrgon http://nike-airmaxcheap.com slhtko nike Running shoe uciacv best nike running shoe mfwvvx Nike Free Running Shoe ojnaac http://nikerunningshoeonline.com lcppsd Nike Blazer Trainers rpbqix nike blazer low trainers zeohqs nike Blazer mid trainers hlkynn http://nikeblazertrainers.com dqyikm Air max France srchbk france air max mwazwl France Air Max xfvnze http://airmaxxfrance.org nhzkmq nike air max online store dmzbzp nike Air max online Store oquwyk Nike Air Max Store zymwcs http://nike-air-maxstore.com dieftr nike Air max tn vdwweh Nike Air Max Tn hbaxta nike Air max plus Tn kimhnw http://nikeair-maxtn.org dkkisx nike running sneakers women dxjxeb Nike running Sneakers fowscj nike Running sneakers for Women sxelck http://nikerunningsneakers.org bzjoxl nike blazer low black bfatqc Nike blazer Vintage Low ksfynf nike Blazer low vintage ehbphf http://nikelowblazers.com onvosh Nike air Max 9 australia wbdhas Nike air Max Australia yeuwrj Nike air Max 9 australia ooytpb http://nike-airmaxaustralia.org kyvryl airmax 97 cvmegr Nike air Max 97 shoes gpdfyc Nike air Max 97 shoes ypdvme http://nikeairmax97shoes.org vtuwxd nike air max 1 sale jvqsyg Air max 1 Sale mvgpfr air max 1 sale hfwimj http://nikeair-max1sale.com nbkiwh Air Max Shoes Cheap mlrbjb air Max shoes cheap kgbiiq Cheap Air Max Shoes ogpoud http://cheapair-maxshoes.org itsbyd Nike Air Max Usa vgkjcb air max usa wiobnr Air max Usa fjnmus http://nikeairmaxusa.org czrdzy air Max 97 silver tqhbdy air Max 97 silver pfayyk air max 97 silver zckftw http://nikeairmax-silver.org jktczk Kids nike Blazers otnlma kids nike blazers ohyokc Nike Blazers For Kids Boys csmurs http://nikeblazersforkids.com hpcqul christian Louboutin shoes uk sekfsl christian louboutin shoes uk dddlqq Christian louboutin Wedding Shoes uk isoqop http://christianllouboutinshoesuk.com ajayqe Cheap Christian Louboutin Uk soxqby Cheap christian Louboutin Shoes vnyglv cheap Christian louboutin uk fhkzyc http://cheapchristianllouboutinshoesuk.com jrueos nike Womens running shoes rcrwju nike Womens running shoes jakmgt Nike running Shoes For women wpadju http://nikewomenrunningshoes.org xttfdq nike Air max 9 Foot locker cuztbt foot Locker air max lvjlnn nike air max 9 foot locker pqwolw http://footlockerairmax.org wzcwhc wholesale air max qihtyd wholesale Air max nhbuwq wholesale air max maoxvc http://whole-saleairmax.org fojzga Nike Neon Pink Running Shoes mkqumc nike neon running shoes myeiqv neon pink nike running shoes twktuc http://nikeneonrunningshoes.com ftinnk Air max 95 Shoes aaswwm nike Airmax 95 fhuftn Airmax 95 mcdhwz http://nikeairmax95shoes.org qndawd louboutin Sale uk qzlsxf Christian louboutin Uk Sale xvlziw christian Louboutin sale uk opmkdj http://christianllouboutinsaleuk.com wdcwic Nike running Shoes Cheap dbqdqc Cheap nike Running Shoes pduhpr Cheap Nike Running Shoes tktwyq http://cheapnike-runningshoes.com pwzbry Air max 9 Laser blue jfaxtx air max 9 laser blue qymaru Blue Air Max 95 hltaik http://airmaxblue.org sjxxbe Hot Pink Nike Running Shoes gxtqly neon Pink nike running Shoes zgjmwg Hot Pink Nike Running Shoes uyiwzw http://pinknikerunningshoes.com qpdhon Air Max Women gjizqd nike air max women gdeogx womens air max ovoeir http://nikeair-maxwomen.com smvhan Nike Pink Running Shoes fexzcm Hot Pink Nike Running Shoes egaqeg Hot Pink Nike Running Shoes dtzelc http://pinknikerunningshoes.net vtkyag nike Running shoes reviews qjdots Nike womens Running Shoes reviews nvkset Nike Running Shoes For Women Reviews dteekk http://nikerunningshoesreviews.com yeteff custom nike air max emhsfk Custom nike Air Max qbiefe custom Nike air max hmmmhl http://customnnikeairmax.org kfwkwg cheap Nike air max Trainers mcupmx Cheap Nike Air Max Trainers omgjvu Cheap Nike Air Max Trainers bilblp http://cheapnikeairmaxtrainers.org udcvts nike air max white osdtlv White air Max fnmlxn Nike air Max White vtfxzr http://nikeairmaxwhite.org apwpad Nike stability Running Shoes men reyqmy nike Stability running shoes qhtyum nike stability running shoes atlqoe http://nikestabilityrunningshoes.com xiftse nike sb blazer high vvdjkr Nike Blazers High Top ehvygn Nike sb Blazer High vrngml http://nikehighblazer.com egxqqf Nike Air Max 36 wnnyqs Air Max 36 nwbvxu air max 36 qaiscq http://nikeairmax360shoes.org rkqzqf Cheap nike Blazer zoofza cheap Nike blazers uk goeurm Cheap nike Blazers For women ffchyd http://nikeblazerscheap.org ynxegd nike Air max pink javtle Nike Air Yeezy Black Pink flpubx air Yeezy black pink zvhjjq http://nikeairmaxpink.org euldsy cheap air max uk oawbcu cheap air max uk uvfkuz Cheap air Max Uk dffjfr http://cheapnikeair-maxuk.com dyhigm Best nike Running Shoes fktofw best nike running shoes for men wfavkt best nike running shoes for women thmhjp http://bestnikerunningshoes.net ggfkmn Buy air Max 9 iohfjs Buy Nike Air Max 9 wugxuu buy Nike air max 95 fwkihd http://buynikeair-max.org aulplw nike blazer online aylhsl Nike Blazer Online Shop gsfjpo Nike Blazer Online jiegfo http://nikeblazeronline.org bdpfpn nike air max uk xdlzaa air Max uk gimlrx Air max Uk mqwpwd http://nikeair-maxuk.com shzzjz nike free running erugma nike free running shoes ulilzg nike Free running ncfigt http://nikefreerunning-shoes.org
Post a Comment
Using this website means you agree to us using simple cookies.