The Ecologist

Pillage theory
The 'pillage theory' is a legal tool that can be used to prosecute corporations involved in the trade in resources such as timber and diamonds originating in conflict zones
More articles about
Related Articles

Pillage theory: a blueprint for prosecuting corporations trading in conflict resources

Matilda Lee

20th April, 2012

Timber, diamonds, gold and oil have long been recognised as drivers of war. But companies involved in trading commodities from conflict zones are seldom prosecuted. Isn't it time they were held to account? Matilda Lee reports

According to the United Nations, at least 18 violent conflicts in the last two decades have been fuelled by the exploitation of countries' natural resources - everything from timber, diamonds, gold, minerals and oil, to land and water. In 2001, the UN General Assembly declared that the 6th November would henceforth be the ‘International Day for Preventing the Exploitation of the Environment in War and Armed Conflict'. But if the environment has historically been the ‘unpublicised victim of war', lawyers and activists are focusing their attention on a new legal tool to curb the conflict resources trade by prosecuting the corporations that are profiting from it. A report, Corporate War Crimes: Prosecuting the Pillage of Natural Resources, by Professor James Stewart, launched at a conference on the same subject in the Hague last year, essentially lays out a blueprint of jurisprudence to hold companies to account for their role in fuelling armed conflict.

Patrick Alley, of UK campaign group Global Witness that has worked for 17 years to expose armed conflict resource corruption, says that to date, efforts to hold corporations accountable have all but failed. ‘Wars from Liberia, to Sierra Leone or Angola all had a natural resource element to them and the exploitation of natural resources helped perpetuate the conflicts. Companies were knowingly doing business in these areas and trading in these resources. Unless this is dealt with, these companies essentially have impunity. They make a profit then leave the country, and the communities have the job of paying for it and picking up the pieces,' he says.

The legal basis centres on the so-called ‘pillage theory' of conflict-related theft, prohibited in international humanitarian law in the 1949 Geneva Convention. Ken Hurwitz, senior anti-corruption legal officer at the Open Society's Justice Initiative, which was involved in preparing the report and the conference says: ‘Jurisprudence is quite volatile at the moment, there are lots of cases going in different directions. The question really boils down to "If I'm buying timber from [former Liberian President] Charles Taylor, and I am therefore giving him money that he uses to arm and equip troops to commit human rights violations, do I share his intent to commit those violations, or is my intent to make money, and does that make a difference?".'

For years, Global Witness, and other civil society groups, pursued the French subsidiary of Danish timber giant DLH through the courts for buying timber from Liberian companies that supported Taylor's regime. They argued that DLH was guilty of ‘recel', the French crime of profiting from goods obtained illegally. ‘We had to try and search jurisdictions to see where a case could be brought. We ended up trying a Danish company in France, all of which is illustrative of the fact that it is not easy. It's an ongoing process and it's taken years. The bottom line is that there never was any prosecution. Now those companies are marketing themselves as super responsible, with FSC certification and the like. Yet, years ago, they were involved in this dirty trade.'

Under the 'pillage theory', there is no requirement of intent to commit the violations that the resources allow to be committed, but rather, ‘an intent to purchase commodities or other assets from somebody who you know doesn't have legal title to them and in the context of an armed conflict,' says Hurwitz. ‘Although none of these cases are simple, we think this is a somewhat more direct and logical, and evidentially easier burden to satisfy on behalf of the prosecutor.' As to why pillage theory itself was never really looked at before, Hurwitz says that in the context in which those situations initially arose, the post World War two cases were different enough from anything people were looking at contemporaneously. 'Nobody really looked but the jurisprudence wasn't really considered particularly on point to the situations human rights activist were focusing on. Then in the DRC [Democratic Republic of Congo] in particular, people were using the word pillage to refer to what was happening economically to the country but everyone was using it as a metaphor - nobody was using it as a technical legal term. Lawyers are sometimes very literal, so the thought was, well, what actually is the crime of pillage? So we looked and found this notion of receiving stolen goods as a type of pillage which seems to have common currency within the jurisprudence, certainly after the World War two period.'

Other guidelines and regulations being developing aim to prevent natural resource trafficking from happening in the first place. One of the provisions in the US Dodd-Frank regulation now being debated relates to ‘conflict minerals', and requires the company bringing materials in from the DRC to the US to show their supply chain due diligence. ‘That in itself is progress,' says Alley. ‘The EU is talking about doing the same thing. But there has been a tremendous push back from industry that could weaken the rule making around this.' The OECD has developed a series of corporate guidelines on due diligence, including in conflict zones. Civil society groups have a critical role to play in raising awareness of supply chains. ‘The whole point of due diligence is the company has to find out where their materials are coming from,' says Alley. 'Our start point is "what is it you are doing to know about your supply chain?" and the response varies. When we can indentify a company buying from conflict zones, we will write to them and engage with them to see what they will do about it.'

One concern about using ‘pillage theory' is how it would impact on communities, such as artisanal miners, who depend on the natural resources trade. ‘It is very often poor people in the battle zone who are mining,' Hurwitz says. 'Technically, if they are mining, and they have no license and they are selling to an armed group, even if at gunpoint, certainly the goal is not to hold them liable for pillage. That's something one would have to be very careful about.' While it is too early to gauge whether the ‘pillage theory' will penetrate into mainstream prosecutorial culture, Hurwitz says the report has led to discussions with a number of authorities in ‘six or so' jurisdictions and he is aware of two or three places where the theory is being pursued actively. ‘We are in an unfortunate situation with the global economy. Prosecutorial agencies are having budget cutbacks meaning there are disincentives for a prosecutor to pursue a new and risky approach to litigation taking on what are probably politically controversial and deep pocketed defendants.'

Even so, 'the UN peacekeeping missions in [Liberia and the DRC] cost of hundreds of millions,' according to Patrick Alley. 'If it had been impossible to launder those natural resources onto the market, it is hard to quantify how much but the impact would have been far less. I would argue that in a sense the international community is subsidising business operation in conflict zones.'

Add to StumbleUpon
7 ways to help stop tropical deforestion & illegal logging
A store like Walmart can wield more power than a country over a logging company - especially in the global South. But what's good for Walmart is not always good for the planet. Peter Dauvergne & Jane Lister outline 7 key tools for retailers to limit the impacts of timber consumption
Revealed: how the Vietnamese military fuels destruction of Laos' forests
Undercover filming by the Environmental Investigation Agency has unearthed shocking evidence of military involvement in the illegal timber trade, all to feed western demand for stylish wood products, according to Faith Doherty
Global Witness quits Kimberley Process as Zimbabwe 'blood diamonds' exported
Consumers could unwittingly buy rings or other jewellery linked to serious human rights abuses after Kimberley Process fails to prevent the sale of diamonds from Robert Mugabe's Marange diamond fields
Trade in precious minerals and timber continues to fuel violence and conflict across the globe
Revenues obtained from the often illegal extraction and supply of commodities such as timber and diamonds are directly bankrolling corrupt regimes and armed insurgency groups, and fund the purchase of weapons and other contraband goods that perpetuate cycles of conflict.
Environmental Investigation Agency: meet the original eco spooks
The EIA has been at the forefront of investigative campaigning for over 25 years, tackling the illegal wildlife trade, timber trafficking and ozone-depleting CFCs. Matilda Lee gets a debriefing


Previous Articles...

Users Comments

2 using hardware capture devices that will convert VHS to MPEG
Posted By Augcd0 1 October 15, 2015 04:03:38 AM

1 cau1110.ft6024 replica million outside of york regional A homeless man was arrested Wednesday Replica cartier tank mc watches evening on charges he stabbed another man behind the Just Brakes at 23124 State Road 54, near the homeless camp where they both lived. When deputies made contact with Eric Weyand in the woods near the Replica reverso watches business, according to the Pasco County Replica rolex sea dweller watches Sheriff's Office report, Weyand asked: "You wanting to know about the guy behind the brake Replica rolex submariner watches place?" Weyand, 43, told deputies he stabbed the man once in the chest with Replica patek philippe calatrava watches a 4 1/2 inch folding knife, which was not recovered, the report said. The victim Kenneth Reese, 28 was taken to a hospital Wednesday evening in critical condition with life threatening injuries. 2. They have tempting delicacies available for purchase and at the back of the box is an open envelope that says, "Please place your $2.00 in the envelope". You don't pay someone and you don't have an option for change from a $5 bill. >When I Replica cartier tank americaine watches came after work last evening, a big box from Amazon was waiting for me! Replica bell ross watches I didn’t expect this, because it slipped Replica cartier tank anglaise watches my mind already that I had ordered this book breitling a7338710 some time ago. Anyway, after unwrapping it, I was immediately impressed Replica audemars piguet royal oak watches by the finish of the book. It wasn’t flimsy (which I exptected it to be, by the price) and the pictures inside were very nicely done at copy cartier watches first glance.Because of the current Euro – US Dollar ratio, it is very interesting for us Europeans to order books, cd’s etc from the USA. This morning, we updated our 2014 financial guidance. We expect revenue growth of approximately 2%; adjusted EPS, excluding amortization, of $6.35 to $6.65; operating cash flow of approximately $780 million to $820 million; and capital expenditures of approximately $185 million to $205 million. The guidance excludes the impact of any share repurchase activity after December 31, 2013.. Globus can also be triggered by an inflammation in the hypopharynx or larynx part of Replica emporio armani watches the throat. This disorder is one of the reasons why throat cancer lumps go undetected. grand carrera calibre 17 rs2 replica People often feel Replica rolex watches bracelets watches stressed that it might be throat cancer, due to the similarity in symptoms. Best to get a timepiece that is highly resistant to the elements. If your special gift is going to be a stylish Replica traditional watches luxury watch, one that might Replica hublot king power watches be worn to work, you should consider a watch that is trendy and cutting edge. It follows that you want a watch that has unusual features, which might include a unique shape, a Replica rolex watches different color face or perhaps a very stylish band. - If you've already decided that Breitling watch you purchase is going to be chic, stylish and extremely functional, you probably want a watch that not only looks good, but always keep great time. Some luxury timepieces come with features that remind a person when it's time to get to their next appointment, while other Replica cartier watches bracelet watches watches keep time through the simple movement of the Breitling. Perhaps you're in the market for a watch that has a more formal, elegant look.

iggy azalea messages on proposal that can computer chip juvenile
Posted By Afqxt1 1 October 15, 2015 04:18:55 PM

DVD burners are becoming more popular and the prices have gone down enormously because of the tremendous growth in the field of computer technology and the use of the internet. The two main types of DVD burners are internal and portable/external burners. Internal DVD burners are compatible with laptops and personal computers. 11 documentaries you can watch these days to know Replica porsche watches how isis raised to force But, Replica limelight watches no one grumbles when the moon shines. Everyone becomes happy and appreciates the moon Replica omega seamaster watches in their own special way. Children watch their shadows and play in its light, people gather at the square to tell stories and dance through the night. 77c in my opinion is acceptable, 90c would have me shutting down. Remember the VRMs can handle 100c, but the components near them can't. (audio and NB) Recapping my temps with small fan not enough to really hear. Replica patek philippe calatrava watches The Board of Directors, I guess that I I don't know, I went in the Replica cartier rotonde watches wrong direction. I skipped which is never a good idea. But the Board of Directors was assembled by the creditors committee back in October and I'd say from the management perspective it's an excellent Board, very involved, very proactive and very, very good experience is Chaired by Pat Wood and Pat is here in Replica tag heuer mercedes benz watches the audience today, in the back sitting next to Hilary Ackermann, also one breitling colt aeromarine of our new Board members Replica hublot king power watches and then, I guess, the three are right there together, Jeff Stein in the back as well.. That is where the TNT Penta pieces come in. With a big date and tri-compax array chronograph, these movements just scream "Dubois-Depraz." Furthering the skeletonized dial concept, the Penta watches have very open dials. How do you Replica breitling superocean watches feel about the very visible big date indicator Replica cartier santos watches discs?Aside from the central seconds hand for the chronograph, this model uses moving discs in relation to red arrows to indicate the information on the subdials. Precision was also achieved in the Replica dancer watches midst of the introduction of the minute hand. High end pouch watches during those times even had smaller bearings in the Replica rendez vous watches direction of tell the seconds. Pocket watches Replica omega watches bracelets watches then became real pocket timepieces. Fond father in law of John Tirado. Life partner of Rev. Terry Troia. In the 401 series of Hamilton it gained or premiered Replica watches bracelets watches in 1934 was Replica cartier ronde solo watches actually an inaccuracy, and refused including Stanley, Livingstone, Byrd, and others. By comparing the his fathers company movements were aatches with the Hamilton. Consequently, the breguet failed the needs in Replica cartier ronde louis watches the year Ernst Jakob Homberger that it actually.

cs0q4f7 insurance
Posted By jibjabst 1 February 21, 2016 09:40:46 PM

ekkjgbut gfqh07at b38d0s0fa fcsany40 inmp8g3u

kx4u8cn insurance
Posted By jibjabst 1 February 25, 2016 10:42:55 PM

m90upw6s vb97jo3g - insurance c72fht9a y98g7xl2

ghdsqdm insurance
Posted By jibjabst 1 February 25, 2016 11:41:33 PM

f14sq997 pd64u37k - insurance v273r0rw qq5xkpqz
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image


Using this website means you agree to us using simple cookies.

More information here...




Help us keep the Ecologist platform going

Since 2012, the Ecologist has been owned and published by a small UK-based charity called the Resurgence Trust. We work hard to support the kind of independent journalism and comment that we know Ecologist readers enjoy but we need your help to keep going. We do all this on a very small budget with a very small editorial team and so joining the Trust or making a donation will show us you value our work and support the platform which is currently offered as a free service.

Join The Resurgence TrustDonate to support the Resurgence Trust