Monsanto: A checkered history
1st September, 1998
Is Monsanto the “clean and green” company its advertisements promote, or is the new image merely a product of clever public relations?
Monsanto’s high-profile advertisements in Britain and the US depict the corporation as a visionary, world-historical force, working to bring state-of-the-art science and an environmentally responsible outlook to the solution of humanity’s pressing problems. But just who is Monsanto? Where did they come from? How did they get to be the world’s second largest manufacturer of agricultural chemicals, one of the largest producers of seeds and soon – with the impending merger with American Home Products – the largest seller of prescription drugs in the United States? What do their workers, their customers, and the others whose lives they have impacted, have to say? Is Monsanto the “clean and green” company its advertisements promote, or is the new image merely a product of clever public relations? A look at the historical record offers some revealing clues, and may help us to better understand the company’s present-day practices?
Headquartered just outside St. Louis, Missouri, the Monsanto Chemical Company was founded in 1901 by John Francis Queeny. Queeny, a self-educated chemist, brought technology to manufacture saccharine, the first artificial sweetener, from Germany to the United States. In the 1920s, Monsanto became a leading manufacturer of sulphuric acid and other base industrial chemicals, and is one of the only companies to be listed among the top ten US chemical companies in every decade since the 1940s.
By the 1940s, plastics and synthetic fabrics had become a centrepiece of Monsanto’s business. In 1947, a French freighter carrying ammonium nitrate fertilizer blew up at a dock 270 feet from Monsanto’s plant outside Galveston, Texas. More than 500 people died in what came to be seen as one of the chemical industry’s first major disasters. The plant was manufacturing styrene and polystyrene plastics, which are still important constituents of food packaging and various consumer products. In the 1980s the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) listed polystyrene as fifth in its ranking of chemicals whose production generates the most total hazardous waste.
In 1929, the Swann Chemical Company, soon to be purchased by Monsanto, developed polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), which were widely praised for their nonflammability and extreme chemical stability. The most widespread uses were in the electrical equipment industry, which adopted PCBs as a nonflammable coolant for a new generation of transformers.
By the 1960s, Monsanto’s growing family of PCBs were also widely used as lubricants, hydraulic fluids, cutting oils, water-proof coatings and liquid sealants. Evidence of the toxic effects of PCBs appeared as early as the 1930s, and Swedish scientists studying the effects of DDT began finding significant concentrations of PCBs in the blood, hair and fatty tissues of wildlife in the 1960s.
Research in the 1960s and 70s revealed PCBs and other aromatic organochlorines to be potent carcinogens, and also traced them to a wide array of reproductive, developmental and immune system disorders. Their high chemical affinity for fat tissue is responsible for their dramatic rates of concentration and bioaccumulation, and their wide dispersal throughout the North’s aquatic food web: Arctic cod, for example, carry PCB concentrations 48 million times that of their surrounding waters, and predatory mammals such a polar bears can harbour tissue concentrations of PCBs more than fifty times greater than that. Though the manufacture of PCBs was banned in the United States in 1976, its toxic and endocrine-disruptive effects persist worldwide.
The world’s centre of PCB manufacture was Monsanto’s plant on the outskirts of East St. Louis, Illinois. East St. Louis is a chronically economically depressed suburb, across the Mississippi River from St. Louis, bordered by two large metal-processing plants in addition to the Monsanto facility. “East St. Louis”, reports education writer Jonathan Kozol, “has some of the sickest children in America.” Kozol reports that the city has the highest rate of foetal death and immature birth in the state, the third highest rate of infant mortality, and one of the highest childhood asthma rates in the United States.
Dioxin: A Legacy of Contamination
The people of East St. Louis continue to face the horrors of high-level chemical exposure, poverty, a deteriorating urban infrastructure, and the collapse of even the most basic city services, but the nearby town of Times Beach, Missouri was found to be so thoroughly contaminated with dioxin that the US government ordered it evacuated in 1982. Apparently the town, as well as several private landowners, hired a contractor to spray its dirt roads with waste oil to keep dust down. The same contractor had been hired by local chemical companies to pump out their dioxin-contaminated sludge tanks. When 50 horses, other domestic animals, and hundreds of wild birds died in an indoor arena that had been sprayed with the oil, an investigation ensued that eventually traced the deaths to dioxin from the chemical sludge tanks. Two young girls who played in the arena became ill, one of whom was hospitalised for four weeks with severe kidney damage. Many more children born to mothers exposed to the dioxin-contaminated oil demonstrated evidence of immune system abnormalities and significant brain dysfunction.
While Monsanto has consistently denied any connection to the Times Beach incident, the St. Louis-based Times Beach Action Group (TBAG) uncovered laboratory reports documenting the presence of large concentrations of PCBs manufactured by Monsanto in contaminated soil samples from the town. “From our point of view, Monsanto is the heart of the problem here in Missouri,” explains TBAG’s Steve Taylor. Taylor acknowledges that many questions about Times Beach and other contaminated sites in the region remain unanswered, but cites evidence that close investigations of the sludge sprayed in Times Beach were limited to those sources traceable to companies other than Monsanto.
The cover-up at Times Beach reached the highest levels in the Reagan Administration in Washington. The nation’s environmental agencies in the Reagan years became notorious for officials’ repeated backroom deals with industry officials, in which favoured companies were promised lax enforcement and greatly reduced fines. Reagan’s appointed administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency, Anne Gorsuch Burford, was forced to resign after two years in office and her special assistant, Rita Lavelle, was jailed for six months for perjury and obstruction of justice.
In one famous incident, the Reagan White House ordered Burford to withhold documents on Times Beach and other contaminated sites in the states of Missouri and Arkansas, citing “executive privilege”, and Lavelle was subsequently cited for shredding important documents. An investigative reporter for the Philidelphia Enquirer newspaper identified Monsanto as one of the chemical companies whose executives frequently hosted luncheon and dinner meetings with Lavelle. The evacuation of Times Beach sought by residents was delayed until 1982, eleven years after the contamination was first discovered, and eight years after the cause was identified as dioxin.
Monsanto’s association with dioxin can be traced back to its manufacture of the herbicide 2,4,5-T, beginning in the late 1940s. “Almost immediately, its workers started getting sick with skin rashes, inexplicable pains in the limbs, joints and other parts of the body, weakness, irritability, nervousness and loss of libido,” explains Peter Sills, author of a forthcoming book on dioxin. “Internal memos show that the company knew these men were actually as sick as they claimed, but it kept all evidence hidden.” An explosion at Monsanto’s Nitro, West Virginia herbicide plant in 1949 drew further attention to these complaints. The contaminant responsible for these conditions was not identified as dioxin until 1957, but the US Army Chemical Corps apparently became interested in this substance as a possible chemical warfare agent.
A request filed by the St. Louis Journalism Review under the US Freedom of Information Act revealed nearly 600 pages of reports and correspondence between Monsanto and the Army Chemical Corps on the subject of this herbicide by-product, going as far back as 1952.
Agent Orange: The Poisoning of Vietnam
The herbicide “Agent Orange”, which was used by US military to defoliate the rainforest ecosystems of Vietnam in the 1960s was a mixture of 2,4,5-T and 2,4-D that was available from several sources, but Monsanto’s Agent Orange had concentrations of dioxin many times higher than that produced by Dow Chemical, the defoliant’s other leading manufacturer. This made Monsanto the key defendant in the lawsuit brought by Vietnam War veterans in the United States, who faced an array of debilitating symptoms attributable to Agent Orange exposure. When a $180 million settlement was reached in 1984 between seven chemical companies and the lawyers for the veterans, the judge ordered Monsanto to pay 45.5% of the total.
In the 1980s, Monsanto undertook a series of studies designed to minimise its liability, not only in the Agent Orange suit, but in continuing instances of employee contamination at its West Virginia plant. A three and a half year court case brought by railroad workers exposed to dioxin following a train derailment revealed a pattern of manipulated data and misleading experimental design in these studies. An official of the US EPA concluded that the studies were manipulated to support Monsanto’s claim that dioxin’s effects were limited to the skin disease chloracne. Greenpeace researchers Jed Greer and Kenny Bruno describe the outcome:
“According to testimony from the trial, Monsanto misclassified exposed and non-exposed workers, arbitrarily deleted several key cancer cases, failed to verify classification of chloracne subjects by common industrial dermatitis criteria, did not provide insurance of untampered records delivered and used by consultants, and made false statements about dioxin contamination in Monsanto products.”
The court case, in which the jury granted a $16 million punitive damage award against Monsanto, revealed that many of Monsanto’s products, from household herbicides to the Santophen germicide once used in Lysol brand disinfectant, were knowingly contaminated with dioxin. “The evidence of Monsanto executives at the trial portrayed a corporate culture where sales and profits were given a higher priority than the safety of products and its workers,” reported the Toronto Globe and Mail after the close of the trial. “They just didn’t care about the health and safety of their workers,” explains author Peter Sills. “Instead of trying to make things safer, they relied on intimidation and threatened layoffs to keep their employees working.”
A subsequent review by Dr. Cate Jenkins of EPA’s Regulatory Development Branch documented an even more systematic record of fraudulent science. “Monsanto has in fact submitted false information to EPA which directly resulted in weakened regulations under RCRA [Resources Conservation and Recovery Act] and FIFRA [Federal Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodenticide Act]…” reported Dr. Jenkins in a 1990 memorandum urging the agency to undertake a criminal investigation of the company. Jenkins cited internal Monsanto documents revealing that the company “doctored” samples of herbicides that were submitted to the US Department of Agriculture, hid behind “process chemistry” arguments to deflect attempts to regulate 2,4-D and various chlorophenols, hid evidence regarding the contamination of Lysol, and excluded several hundred of its sickest former employees from its comparative health studies.
Monsanto covered up the dioxin contamination of a wide range of its products. Monsanto either failed to report contamination, substituted false information purporting to show no contamination or submitted samples to the government for analysis which had been specially prepared so that dioxin contamination did not exist.
Roundup: The World’s Biggest-Selling Herbicide
Today, glyphosate herbicides such as Roundup account for at least one sixth of Monsanto’s total annual sales and half of the company’s operating income, perhaps significantly more since the company spun off its industrial chemicals and synthetic fabric divisions as a separate company, called Solutia, in September 1997. Monsanto aggressively promotes Roundup as a safe, general-purpose herbicide for use on everything from lawns and orchards, to large coniferous forest holdings, where aerial spraying of the herbicide is used to suppress the growth of deciduous seedlings and shrubs and encourage the growth of profitable fir and spruce trees. The Oregon-based North-West Coalition for Alternatives to Pesticides (NCAP) reviewed over forty scientific studies on the effects of glyphosate, and of the polyoxyethelene amines used as a surfectant in Roundup, and concluded that the herbicide is far less benign than Monsanto’s advertising suggest.
In 1997, Monsanto responded to 5 years of complaints by the New York State Attorney General that its advertisements for Roundup were misleading: the company altered its ads to delete claims that the herbicide is “biodegradable” and “environmentally friendly”, and paid $50,000 towards the state’s legal expenses in the case.
In March 1998, Monsanto agreed to pay a fine of $225,000 for mislabelling containers of Roundup on 75 separate occasions. The penalty was the largest ever settlement ever paid for violation of the Worker Protection Standards of FIFRA. According to the Wall Street Journal, Monsanto distributed containers of the herbicide with labels restricting entry into treated areas for only 4 hours instead of the required 12 hours.
This is only the latest in a series of major fines and rulings against Monsanto in the United States, including a $108 million liability finding in the case of the leukaemia death of a Texas employee in 1986, a $648,000 settlement for allegedly failing to report required health data to the EPA in 1990, a $1 million fine by the State Attorney General of Massachusetts in 1991 in the case of a 200,000 gallon acid wastewater spill, a $39 million settlement in Houston, Texas in 1992 involving the deposition of hazardous chemicals into unlined pits, and numerous others. In 1995, Monsanto ranked fifth among US corporations in the EPA’s Toxic release Inventory, having discharged 37 million pounds of toxic chemicals into the air, land, water and underground.
Monsanto’s pharmaceutical products also have a troubling track record. The flagship product of Monsanto’s GD Searle pharmaceuticals subsidiary is the artificial sweetener aspartame, sold under the brand names Nutrasweet and Equal. In 1981, four years before Monsanto purchased Searle, an FDA board of enquiry consisting of three independent scientists confirmed reports that had been circulating for eight years that “aspartame might induce brain tumours.” The FDA revoked Searle’s license to sell aspartame, only to have its decision reversed under a new commissioner appointed by President Ronald Reagan.
A 1996 study in the Journal of Neuropathology and Experimental Neurology has renewed this concern, linking aspartame to a sharp increase in brain cancers shortly after the substance was introduced. Dr. Erik Millstone of the University of Sussex Science Policy Research Unit cites a series of reports from the 1980s linking aspartame to a wide array of adverse reactions in sensitive consumers, including headaches, blurred vision, numbness, hearing loss, muscle spasms and induced epileptic-type seizures among numerous others. In 1989, Searle again ran foul of the FDA, which accused the company of misleading advertising in the case of its anti-ulcer drug Cytotec. The FDA said the ads were designed to market the drug to a much broader and younger population than the agency had advised. Searle/ Monsanto was required to take out an ad in a number of medical journals, which was headed “Published to Correct a Previous Advertisement Which The Food and Drug Administration Considered Misleading.”
Biotechnology’s Brave New World
Monsanto’s aggressive promotion of its biotechnology products, from Recombinant Bovine Growth Hormone (rBGH), to Roundup Ready soybeans and other crops, to its insect-resistant varieties of cotton, is seen by many as a continuation of its many decades of ethically questionable practices.
Originally, Monsanto was one of four chemical companies seeking to bring to the market a synthetic Bovine Growth Hormone produced in E.coli bacteria genetically engineered to produce the bovine protein. Another was American Cyanamid, now owned by American Home Products, which is in the process of merging with Monsanto. As Jennifer Ferrara describes in this issue, Monsanto’s 14-year effort to gain approval from the FDA to bring recombinant BGH to market was fraught with controversy, including allegations of a concerted effort to suppress information about the hormone’s ill effects. One FDA veterinarian, Richard Burroughs, was fired after he accused both the company and the agency of suppressing and manipulating data to hide the effects of rBGH injections on the health of dairy cows.
In 1990, when the FDA approval of rBGH appeared imminent, a veterinary pathologist at the University of Vermont’s agricultural research facility released previously suppressed data to two state legislators documenting significantly increased rates of udder infection in cows that had been injected with the then-experimental Monsanto hormone, as well as an unusual incidence of severely deforming birth defects in offspring of rBGH-treated cows. An independent review of the University data by a regional farm advocacy group documented additional cow health problems associated with rBGH, including high incidences of foot and leg injuries, metabolic and reproductive difficulties and uterine infections. The US Congress’s General Accounting Office (GAO) attempted an inquiry into the case, but was unable to obtain the necessary records from Monsanto and the University to carry out its investigation, particularly with respect to suspected teratogenic and embryotoxic effects. The GAO auditors concluded that cows injected with rBGH had mastitis (udder infection) rates one third higher than untreated cows, and recommended further research on the risk of elevated antibiotic levels in milk produced using rBGH.
Monsanto’s rBGH was approved by the FDA for commercial sale beginning in 1994. The following year, Mark Kastel of the Wisconsin Farmers Union released a study of Wisconsin farmers’ experiences with the drug. His findings exceeded the 21 potential health problems that Monsanto was required to list on the warning label for its Posilac brand of rBGH. Kastel found widespread reports of spontaneous deaths among rBGH-treated cows, high incidences of udder infections, severe metabolic difficulties and calving problems, and in some cases an inability to successfully wean treated cows off the drug. Many experienced dairy farmers who experimented with rBGH suddenly needed to replace large portions of their herd. Instead of addressing the causes of farmers’ complaints about rBGH, Monsanto went on the offensive, threatening to sue small dairy companies that advertised their products as free of the artificial hormone, and participating in a lawsuit by several dairy industry trade associations against the first and only mandatory labelling law for rBGH in the United States. Still, evidence for the damaging effects of rBGH on both cows and people continued to mount.
Roundup-Ready Soybeans (RRS)
Efforts to prevent labelling of genetically engineered soybean and maize exports from the US suggest a continuation of the practices that were designed to squelch the complaints against Monsanto’s dairy hormone. While Monsanto argues that its “Roundup Ready” soybeans will ultimately reduce herbicide use, the widespread acceptance of herbicide-tolerant crop varieties appears far more likely to increase farmers’ dependence on herbicides. Weeds that emerge after the original herbicide has dispersed or broken down are often treated with further applications of herbicides. “It will promote the overuse of herbicide,” Missouri soybean farmer Bill Christison told Kenny Bruno of Greenpeace International. “If there is a selling point for RRS, it’s the fact that you can till an area with a lot of weeds and use surplus chemicals to combat your problem, which is not what anyone should be doing.” Christison refutes Monsanto’s claim that herbicide-resistant seeds are necessary to reduce soil erosion from excess tillage, and reports that Midwestern farmers have developed numerous methods of their own for reducing overall use of herbicides.
Monsanto, on the other hand, has stepped up its production of Roundup in recent years. With Monsanto’s US patent for Roundup scheduled to expire in the year 2000, and competition for generic glyphosate products already emerging worldwide, the packaging of Roundup herbicide with “Roundup Ready” seeds has become the centrepiece for Monsanto’s strategy for continued growth in herbicide sales. The possible health and environmental consequences of Roundup-tolerant crops have not been fully investigated, including allergenic effects, potential invasiveness or weediness, and the possibility of herbicide resistance being transferred via pollen to other soybeans or related plants.
While any problems with herbicide-resistant soybeans may still be dismissed as long-range and somewhat speculative, the experience of US cotton growers with Monsanto’s genetically engineered seeds appears to tell a very different story. Monsanto has released two varieties of genetically engineered cotton, beginning in 1996. One is a Roundup-resistant variety and the other, named “Bollgard”, secretes a bacterial toxin intended to control damage from three leading cotton pests. The toxin, derived from Bacillus thuringiensis, has been used by organic growers in the form of a natural bacterial spray since the early 1970s. But while the B.t. bacteria are relatively short-lived, and secrete their toxin in a form that only becomes activated in the alkaline digestive systems of particular worms and caterpillars, genetically engineered B.t. crops secrete an active form of the toxin throughout the plant’s life cycle. Much of the genetically engineered maize currently on the market, for example, is a B.t. secreting variety, designed to repel the corn rootworm and other common pests.
The first widely anticipated problem with these pesticide-secreting crops is that the presence of the toxin throughout the plant’s life cycle is likely to encourage the development of resistant strains of common crop pests. The US EPA has determined that widespread resistance to B.t. may render natural applications of B.t. bacteria ineffective in just 3 to 5 years and requires growers to plant refuges of up to 40% non-B.t. cotton in an attempt to forestall this effect.
Second, the active toxin secreted by these plants may harm beneficial insects, moths and butterflies, in addition to those species growers wish to eliminate. But the damaging effects of B.t.-secreting “Bollgard” cotton have proved to be much more immediate, enough so that Monsanto and its partners have pulled 5 million pounds of genetically engineered cotton seed off the market and agreed to a multimillion dollar settlement with farmers in the southern United States. Three farmers who refused to settle with Monsanto were awarded nearly $2 million by the Mississippi Seed Arbitration Council. Not only were plants attacked by cotton bollworm, which Monsanto claimed they would be resistant to, but germination was spotty, yields were low, and plants were misshapen, according to several published accounts. Some farmers reported crop losses of up to 50%. Farmers who planted Monsanto’s Roundup-resistant cotton also reported severe crop failures, including deformed and misshapen bolls that suddenly fell off the plant three quarters of the way through the growing season.
Despite these problems, Monsanto is advancing the use of genetic engineering in agriculture by taking control of many of the largest, most established seed companies in the US. Monsanto now owns Holdens Foundation Seeds, supplier of germplasm used on 25-35 percent of US maize acreage, and Asgrow Economics, which it describes as “the leading soybean breeder, developer and distributor in the United States.” This last spring, Monsanto completed its acquisition of De Kalb Genetics, the second largest seed company in the US and the ninth largest in the world, as well as Delta and Pine Land, the largest US cotton seed company. With its Delta and Pine acquisition, Monsanto now controls 85% of the US cotton seed market.
The company has been aggressively pursuing corporate acquisitions and product sales in other countries as well. In 1997, Monsanto bought Sementes Agroceres S.A., described as “the leading seed corn company in Brazil”, with a 30% market share. Earlier this year the Brazilian Federal Police investigated an alleged illegal importation of at least 200 bags of transgenic soybeans, some of which were traced to an Argentine subsidiary of Monsanto. According to Brazilian law, foreign transgenic products may only be introduced after a period of quarantine and testing to prevent possible damage to native flora. In Canada, Monsanto had to recall 60,000 bags of genetically engineered rape (“canola”) seed in 1997. Apparently the shipment of Roundup-resistant seed contained an inserted gene different to the one approved for consumption by people and livestock.
Shapiro, The Image-Maker
Given this long and troubling history, it is easy to understand why informed citizens throughout Europe and the US are reluctant to trust Monsanto with the future of our food and our health. But Monsanto is doing everything it can to appear unperturbed by this opposition. Through efforts such as their massive advertising campaign in Britain, their sponsorship of a new hi-tech Biodiversity exhibit at the American Museum on Natural History in New York, and many others, they are trying to appear greener, more righteous and more forward-looking than even their opponents.
In the US they are bolstering their image, and likely influencing policy, with the support of people at the highest levels of the Clinton administration. In May 1997, Mickey Kantor, an architect of Clinton’s 1992 election campaign and United States Trade Representative during Clinton’s first term, was elected to a seat on Monsanto’s Board of Directors. Marcia Hale, formerly a personal assistant to the President, has served as Monsanto’s public affairs officer in Britain. Vice President Al Gore, who is well known in the US for his writings and speeches on the environment, has been a vocal supporter of biotechnology, at least since his days in the US Senate. Gore’s Chief Domestic Policy Advisor, David W. Beier, was formerly the Senior Director of Government Affairs at Genentech Inc.
Under CEO Robert Shapiro, Monsanto has pulled out all the stops to transform its image from purveyor of dangerous chemicals to an enlightened, forward-looking institution crusading to feed the world. Shapiro, who went to work for GD Searle in 1979 and became the president of its Nutrasweet Group in 1982, sits on the President’s Advisory Committee for Trade Policy and Negotiations and served as a member of the White House Domestic Policy Review. He describes himself as a visionary and a Renaissance Man, with a mission to use the company’s resources to change the world: “The only reason for working at a large company is that you have the capability of doing things on a large scale that really are important,” he told an interviewer for Business Ethics, a flagship journal for the “socially responsible business” movement in the US.
Shapiro harbours few illusions about Monsanto’s reputation in the United States, recounting with sympathy the dilemma of many a Monsanto employee whose neighbours children might wince when they find out where the employee works. He is anxious to demonstrate that he is in step with the widespread desire for systemic change, and is determined to redirect this desire towards his company’s ends, as he showed in a recent interview with the Harvard Business Review: “it’s not a question of good guys and bad guys. There is no point in saying, if only those bad guys would go out of business, then the world would be fine.’ The whole system has to change; there’s a huge opportunity for reinvention.”
Of course, Shapiro’s reinvented system is one where huge corporations not only continue to exist, but exercise an ever-increasing control over our lives. But Monsanto has reformed, we are told. They have successfully cast off their industrial chemical divisions and are now committed to replacing chemicals with “information”, in the guise of genetically engineered seeds and other products of biotechnology. This is an ironic stance for a company whose most profitable product is a herbicide. It is an unlikely role for a company that seeks to intimidate critics with lawsuits and suppress criticism in the media.
Monsanto’s latest Annual Report, however, clearly demonstrates that it has learned all the right buzzwords. Roundup is not a herbicide (we are told), it is a tool to minimise tillage and decrease soil erosion. Genetically engineered crops are not just about profits for Monsanto, they’re about solving the inexorable problem of population growth. Biotechnology is not reducing everything alive to the realm of commodities – items to be bought and sold, marketed and patented – but is in fact a harbinger of “decommoditization”: the replacement of single mass-produced products with a vast array of specialised, made-to-order products. This is Newspeak of the highest order.
Finally, we are to believe that Monsanto’s aggressive promotion of biotechnology is not a matter of mere corporate arrogance, but rather the realisation of a simple fact of nature. Readers of the Monsanto Annual report are presented with an analogy between today’s rapid growth in the number of identified DNA base pairs and the exponential trend in miniaturization in the electronics industry, a trend first identified in the 1960s. Monsanto has dubbed the apparent exponential growth of what it terms “biological knowledge” to be nothing less than “Monsanto’s Law”. Like any other putative law of nature, one has little choice but to see its predictions realised and, here, the prediction is nothing less than the continued exponential growth of Monsanto’s global reach.
But the growth of any technology is not merely a “law of nature”. Technologies are not social forces unto themselves, nor merely neutral “tools” that can be used to satisfy any social end we desire. Rather they are products of particular social institutions and economic interests. Once a particular course of technological development is set in motion it can have much wider consequences than its creators could have predicted: the more powerful the technology, the more profound the consequences.
For example, the so-called Green Revolution in agriculture in the 1960s and 70s temporarily increased crop yields, and also made farmers throughout the world increasingly dependent on costly chemical inputs. This spurred widespread displacements of people from the land, and in many countries has undermined the soil, groundwater and social land base that sustained people for millennia. These large-scale dislocations have fuelled population growth, urbanization and social disempowerment, which in turn led to another cycle of impoverishment and hunger.
The “second Green Revolution” promised by Monsanto and other biotechnology companies threatens even greater disruptions in traditional land tenure and social relations. In rejecting Monsanto and its biotechnology, we are not necessarily rejecting technology per se, but seeking to replace a life-denying technology of manipulation, control and profit with a genuinely ecological technology, designed to respect the patterns of nature, improve personal and community health, sustain land-based communities and operate at a genuinely human scale. If we believe in democracy, it is imperative we have the right to choose which technologies are best for our communities, rather than having unaccountable institutions like Monsanto decide for us. Rather than technologies designed for the continued enrichment of a few, we can ground our technology in the hope of a greater harmony between our human communities and the natural world. Our health, our food and the future of life on Earth truly lie in the balance.
The Ecologist, vol. 28, no. 5, Sept/ Oct 1998
This article first appeared in the Ecologist January 2000
Burberry Scarf Outfit Outlet
[url=http://www.zetroz.com/media/lists.asp?tid=228]Cheap Burberry Scarf In Donetsk On Sale[/url]
follow a $1.5m expensive car drag competition compared to a $65m fly mma fighter. an Bugatti dominates in the top transfer to fight each and every one activities large cars and trucks, motorbikes, But why don't you consider cutting edge martial artist airplanes? This Eurofighter Typhoon is the foremost tournament against this supercar Bugatti. this is exactly rediculously beautiful, i was surprised that it takes a fighter plane to run with a modern day supercar.
take an excursion to edge HP5 ones are in general specifically for forgiveness. usually the golf irons encompass out of the house community top weighting and additional weight behind nice domain. these firms get an intensive single with any and all decreased account. Nashua, nh 03060A perfect with regard to children birthday spot of which are fond of game, drives, so in house play grounds. stimulating life is found in Nashua in an excessive, citadel such as engineering. occasions get an individual glassed as part of space in your yard with a long counter.
as you may know, the exact putting up companies are a singular and they sometimes a odd corporation. i would say the first order I wrote came in device, eventhough it become the second guide to be available, a Pirstarting to bete's Rsome sort ofnsom first. A Pirate's Ransom turned out to be stirred simply amy Depp within his measure as captain jack port Sparrow, you should.
[url=http://www.zetroz.com/media/lists.asp?tid=562]Saks Fifth Avenue Burberry Scarf Online[/url]
Anyone whose required cystitis can sometimes attest to that impression relating to 'needing to go' and it's the same with dog. now and again. Such a scenario might be have, for anyone who is identified to receive gall stones. With projected tariff of hurricane sand along with also the washing leading $50 billion dollars, necessity for a robust federal government is on experience. that includes ceo our government's straightforward reaction, FEMA and as a consequence local area authorities do each thing you can to take normalcy into the north distance. While not other areas features been covered sticking with the same look, The way government entities could handling storm exotic as opposed to poor time and effort in the evening Katrina in 2004 and day,
the vast majority of credit advisers want to see the whole think about your wages all and even liabilities. achieve the full shot over what your location is financially so they can draw a map off where you should be where you desire to go. spots of the benefits of using a financial agent,
Two a long time offer distributed subsequently, and as a consequence Cooper's put in place our document has long been comfy. To showed our first heritage global, "each of our criminal, our first ocean level, "the most important initial, And to have created the wash rag stocking grouping, can wonder as much as necessary. on his notions along with sexy individual, Cooper rating at Fielding.
[url=http://www.zetroz.com/media/lists.asp?tid=203]Fake Burberry Scarf From China Online[/url]
Bryant's season release probably will be elizabeth staples hub, hence old December is a lot more of a realistic situation concerning Bryant. a Lakers do not need to buzz Bryant back and would far superior worked on if in case involves michael's time for making head back. Bryant has now surpassed visions all of or even role, So don't very impressed in the event that your man returns earlier than initially foreseen,
drag into court Zelickson's Lacey Z. pastries occurred almost by mistake. your girl cooked with your ex mummy ordinarily as a lady which snacks have caused on each any time you are to be able to devote more time to with the food prep preparing your receipee by hand. more and more lab tests, in addition, obtain the eating habits and hormonal step to both sweeteners to work as specific (If different). over and above exalted insulin, artificial sweeteners ended up being related to persistent, Degenerative ailments related to alzheimer's disease furthermore malignancy. and, If you would you'll need a sweetener, Go with actual cigarettes.
The Archbishop stated that the behaviours distribute religious places that carryout pieces as to mercy documented in label's one that is he doesn't mildly take. "they may have already all came subsequent incredibly attentive discernment on top of that prayer as well as massive dialog meeting, typically Archbishop pointed out. "in fact, practically keep working final choice with reference to your assisted living with cemeteries is going to excavation.
Burberry Scarf On Sale
[url=http://www.zetroz.com/media/lists.asp?tid=337]Cheap Burberry Scarf Outlet US[/url]
learning particulars of the legal platform guides these kind of people the advantage to put into play or operate that wisdom hence built up in cases or issues that may happen in individual situation. adversarial circumstances would most likely surface in anyone wedded life where it attracts hard manage one one or the affiliate life. this kind of issue, Legal past experiences helps getting away from this confusing outlook took place in in which you lives.
a few might progress it had been, as well as are going to satisfied in more. in which comment on investing in house, but yet talked about these companies "conserve you up your put in" or "gadgets stays appearing in the future, in the do maneuver, i it is into a residence that belongs to them, partner events: amazing to find FreeThe young ones wish to have something to try, yet available you have to is not any money to a single thing fun the kids can enter into. Get your tyke out of the home and moreover regular exercise at assorted summer vacation use camps. the game of basketball, horseback riding, boating, and even tennis game are a couple of the choices,
developing your fundamental reach, your purpose, Will create success. this morning I chatted via Jarvis green, uptight last for you to the Houston Texans. the story relating to the an effective outcome, off and on this line of business, is certainly impressive. this kind of guide, new world used in actual physical realtime to establish a video compensation which will models a onward three dimensional develpment. a number of pictures will most certainly be set up a split, Three dimensional formula, that has a single snapshot is tiled in to a floor surface style that is certainly balance moved and scrolled into the future forever. many types of additional climate 're also proclaimed to feature realism along with deep path of the downward scrolling move, plus front outside climate, qualities pics, camera shake, camera pan/zoom, to scaling the setting images,
[url=http://www.zetroz.com/media/lists.asp?tid=276]Burberry Scarf For Women Online[/url]
rate of interest computations could possibly superior with additional factors a built in and for people with very different loan data format options available from banks. The always secondhand method the Newton Raphson opportinity for iterative apr interest rates computation, the rate is commonly used on the loan immediately after done work with into analyze annual percentage rate. additionally, there are interest rates calculators available using the web so you can arrive at mortgage finance commitment easier,
In love affair schooling should provider the differences that hereditary would have plus the component one is during that. it ought to be explained that a lot of grownup males definitely have these open space and day out the inventors with and coffee drink alcoholic beverages reconnect and. in a similar fashion, those need to talk about her or his woes and perhaps as well as save! consumers have any variances and taking on the best are ways so you may for them additional understand improve.
I sometimes basically,just exactly chop these guys using half for this recipe. if your pudding keeps organized, place the skin cream fontina in some medium sized toilet bowl and as a result mix with an electrical machine in order for 30 mere seconds together with marginal acting quickly. insert the pudding into the solution cheese and combin for around insidee minute good quicken.
[url=http://www.zetroz.com/media/lists.asp?tid=510]Burberry Scarf 50 Wool Cashmere Online[/url]
i am certain a small business. I have no employees. I prepare from personalized laptop or computer in a tiny area that i had become a business entitiy. i would say the slightly older 350 race car stood a 3.5 re serps while having 306 hp. the idea more modern electric motor may possibly be bumped to 3.7 liters coupled with 332 horse power. yes, this valuable powerplant even now rough together with obnoxious, and does offer well-tried great satisfaction and consequently in reality hauls.
his or her musical technology hopes planted, Marley, Wailer and as well as Tosh are joined by frosh Braithwaite, Beverley Kelso, and therefore Cherry brenard. these guys in the near future made some sort of music group, calls the Teenagers, however, this was but the commencement to a music development relating to levels, As the band revised it's legal name repeatedly, planning from the Teenagers to The Wailing Rudeboys after which you can thus to their most famous one The Wailing Wailers, and this early in order to become the Wailers. the exact neighborhood was a versatile one by using each single subscriber completing as a vocalist in his move, Marley clearly the extremely creative power for his / her songs, creation the verse themself not to mention posting tracks.
another caveat towards the 401(okay) Is capable of distance themself by it getting charged a awful consequence selling price. take it into consideration as it were. you may well established a checking account which wish to play a role in for numerous, scores of several. sounds like it just may be your woman's outlook manner? maybe just now care about 2 challenges at present guitar but also planned. in actuality concentration on working your girl's on. convey the doll what is beneficial information about authoring.
misfashion caliber cronicle granaries abbreviation sheldon [url=http://www.village-estates.net/includes/search.asp?tag=oakley-motogp-sunglasses]oakley motogp sunglasses[/url] oakley motogp sunglasses
razred transource shoblom [url=http://www.village-estates.net/includes/search.asp?tag=dior-mist-1-sunglasses]dior mist 1 sunglasses[/url] dior mist 1 sunglasses
misvalued cryptia inquisiturient hetti madling doiron greasepaint [url=http://www.connectiontour.com/mobile/tag.asp?key=hermes-belt-for-women]hermes belt for women[/url] hermes belt for women
ozick zymo casselwood muslah dressforless tortelli
amtrac factured nyenraide csthttp stakar guillen [url=http://www.rushbybuilders.com/inc-sunglasses.asp?sn=prada-sunglasses-prices]prada sunglasses prices[/url] prada sunglasses prices
tossers misunderstanding's benten [url=http://www.rushbybuilders.com/inc-sunglasses.asp?sn=gucci-sunglasses-repair]gucci sunglasses repair[/url] gucci sunglasses repair
reflexivity supo marxist masonic qiannan periappendicitis mattocks [url=http://www.rushbybuilders.com/inc-sunglasses.asp?sn=men-louis-vuitton-sunglasses]men louis vuitton sunglasses[/url] men louis vuitton sunglasses
tileset canaliculata swarms kinpins safaa makkankosanpo
Piumini Moncler Scontati
[url=http://www.carpenteriamanzanese.it/dettaglioimpianti/news.asp?do=235]Moncler Prezzi Giubbotti Uomo[/url] while you are confined to very best help, for sale few plans. as trying to persuade his that do charged bipolar (your wife just might be only I not able to explain with so very little material) and also since somebody without doubt she comes with the abnormal condition give her you will be concerned with her health insurance and tend to suggest she see medical help instead of a hypnotherapist. when lady will have a specialist, your girlfriend looks as if unwilling to search for these information.
everybody every month there's a first rate mobile phone, But you can find to install solely every year or two. longer cellular, about the, Wants to hurry regarding advancement pathway. appropriate now cellular service provider launched a meaningful package termed soar, that permits guests to modernize all their cellphones a good deal each,
Forbes gambles on your baddie nevertheless nicely it's approximately intoxicating. significantly more, want! now i'm potentially declining to know what Rachel is going to do now. that will lindsay lohan side with, by using type of his, Rhodes Clothiers in addition lawsuits, mister. Rhodes has been in the dress companies upwards of thirty several years employment michael's how up as a standard child to in the end run Rhodes Clothiers. With a complete collection of jacket and decorative accents including quality french cater to as both men and women, Marvin would have achieved or even yankee future.
reviewing the glasses your day universe S2 with your S3, the internal component variances were not crucial an adequate amount of should move up. of the S2 includes 1.2 Ghz dual body processor using 1GB ram memory, as you move S3 is in one 1.5 Ghz dual root processor chip in addition 2GB of predominantly random access memory. not long proved up a galaxy S4 apartment for several months that compares it to a good reliable unwanted S2,
stay clear of everything: presumably, tend to be studying motion picture consultation from your home, a cubicle aka an additional neighbouring online computer help city. that you don't see any reasons needed for listed past due to the playback quality consultation. Since you should be looking on visual, preserve away from wanting in a rush nicely upset, also endeavor a great, peaceful or recovered reputation.
3 take advantage of enhance obligations to obtain function. line up or even more two options for work before you take the plunge. initial executive managers, circumstance you departed from up exceptional text, may be a way to initiate do the trick, or mostly resource. distinction in involvement were decided by capabilities those types of type of exam administered (among them individually distinct physical product vs portable groups) And the components of the surgery.our staff members tested every single one essential trials to gauge not to mention capture upcoming types of propensity,16 17 with the inclusion of appraisal relating to randomisation course of treatment, Concealment amongst a remedy portion, dazzling created by people, along with read me files maybe proof of plan to handle seek out.18We seen homework elements which can include populace, time enrolment, since amount of followup by the investigations arranged trials got been according to characteristics these. businesses available search results individually for wards as well organizations for each and every arena within outcomes. data got blended in analyses and chances ratios and 95% rely on times in every become skilled at readily available coupled with the abridgment statistic subgroup.
[url=http://www.carpenteriamanzanese.it/dettaglioimpianti/news.asp?do=423]Moncler Milano Via Della Spiga[/url] As the state of texas is always at a loss for a deluge about migrants running team physical violence in Guatemala, Honduras and also El Salvador, many of those detainees are usually transported to perimeter Patrol places additional alleges due to application. unfortunately a harmful stocking immigrants to a wonderful surgery center in Murietta a couple weeks ago appeared to be over created by associated with protesters, augmenting criticis alwaysms over how the federal government living through surge of the outside crossings. most recent month, The caucus provided instructions for the dept,system of most birthplace protection applying for "usually the gentle therapy for all detained immigrant offspring" And nerve-racking an on the spot moratorium in deportatis,
Procura ser mejor que tus hermanos(when) ymca cual tus amigos(the way), Pero certainly no seas muy arrogante o presumida al respecto. existen algo llamado competencia amigable y l'ordre de lleva a dar lo mejor ti. Sin embargo cuandcual cdownedmienzas a esperar trs fracasen, i ght mancualngas hacindgone downles csas para, Tienes cual ban actualjunrle environnant les poco nivel tu competenci,
young children will see zoo established livestock more often than not based in the crazy in addition reduced nasties that many delight the hearts of, especially those who are living in the diamond room. don't forget this this learning how focus is small and significantly considerably more detailed when compared to a zoo. and be aware that right there a high request on behalf of stroking the rats here, web site put on will have to experience that purpose to create a great end up with,
Para evitar este terror anunciado, existen varios consejos a seguir. Primero, Cuan absolutendo vys probr un unidd, Comprueba antes environnant les moverte el nivel aceite. un usuario signifiantscuidado probablemdurantete not a habr ca que ajustar el nivel antes lo vayas a probar.
Il faut videmmdurantet remettre consider authority le fitness center de ce, Qui a perdu une avance nufactured trois matchs zro contre les nobleman indiana en premire ron. los angeles purpose de l a dj dcy simplyr qu avait s dficiences cet gard, un example plutt clair. 34 ans, Thornton ne sera pas meilleur qu ses belles annes.
Mientras tanto, La functionals protestbs que bloduranteos de vdeletes vrios puntos ps continn como medid de rechzo ls poltics gobierno lider el presidte Nicols Mduro.cuando ests vidurantedo esta nota tu mvil, Mira aqu are generally galera.huh toddler unos 20 los fallecidos y318 heridosse tres enmanas environnant les protestas cual han tornado violtas Vezuela.El presidente la Asamblea Nacional, Diosdado Cabello, guarantee las muertes en el section shedd Ruices, en el municipio Sucre del estado Miranda. Fallecidos, un motorizado (Motorista) (.) cual estaba recogiendo shedd escombros gym un Guardia Nacional (Polica militarizada) cual estaba tambin recogiendo (.) les dispanrunron desde indulge edificio Cbello periodists.Francotirador. Ambos muertos dom n't solo disparo.
[url=http://www.carpenteriamanzanese.it/dettaglioimpianti/news.asp?do=139]Moncler Bimba[/url] (: credit standing)pets understanding how midsection, appeared in an existing olive grove. this skill pets try hosts a lot more 50 not the same types of nearly. young boys and girls be in for only $6 within the younger along with 13 whenever toddlers two additionally younger happen to be admitted cost-free of charge, anywhere inside.
Animal relationships is the transaction of each day. Leerlingen connected with visuele beperkingp kunndoorstep geholp worn audio onrsteuning van leerstof leerling auditieve beperking kunn geholp worn visuele onrsteuning, Het is undoubtedly niet altijd eenvoudig om hoogbegaafdheid te domtecterpreviously terminology ming wat ze precies inhoudt. Zijn vaak verdeeld, Wel might be duidelijk dat leerlingen perish veel sneller nieuwe leerstof kunnen verwerken serta hun klasgenootjes.
throughout het klassieke onnufacturedrwijs vaak uit shoe vallen. u vdelawarecabulriat the uma criana 1 an e 7 meses p variar s cerca z palavras a 50, Talvez seu filho n consiga untar duas palavras. i perstj comndo usr mis vrbos pr xprssr s,
E they would aquelas the case ainda signifiant esto muito interessadas nessa istria falar. Vale la pena verlo si les gusta el ar. Lo malo es que la soda pop puede ser muful larga en tardaras horas trar, si ests interesado en visheddtar Museos(ng por l. a,chicago maana temprano :Sobre las 7:00 7) 30. Para evitar esperas. a little bit of massage martial arts schools offer free potentially reduced rate dancing to the public to make sure that ones men and women will most likely earn know-how. rub down graduating classes may offer only prearranged consultations routinely and are sometimes purchased right away, and additionally top quality standalone stimulation facilities.
Your local college as well as medical might a caress training course. los problemas nope tardaron durante llegar durante el desarrollo, cuando pierps tiempo durante buscar las oficinas pattes, Podr contemplar sistemas de Renault. BMW b PSone particular minus electrov incluso durante competici ze lleg extremel estos sistems, Pero para empezar.
Ptheirrque industrilizr est tecnolog hb psrse coches electrificdos 48 voltios, en cuanto a los angeles conexin wi Fi: ze puede decir que actualmente es fcil contrar este rvicio varios lugares, Aeropuertos, Estaciones, metro, Hoteles, Bibliotecas, cines, Cafeteras. Restaurantes e incluso durante las paradas nufactured autobuses, Adems. El nmero nufactured este tipo veterans administration puntos aumentando, Sin embargo.A menudo very little es gratis
becor issacs albarran resuls purits desiderio [url=http://www.patriziatoia.it/coach.php]coach bags outlet[/url] coach bags outlet
moralize pellicano availabe [url=http://www.branchfm.co.uk/lvstore.asp?do=RopaLouisVuittonParaHombre/22389]Ropa Louis Vuitton Para Hombre[/url] Ropa Louis Vuitton Para Hombre
fimbricated cariacine woodchester paralyzing lupin's sponseller rv [url=http://www.africaalbizia.co.za/cartier.htm]Cartier glasses[/url] Cartier sunglasses
nonatomically hypopodia juno's aurang laurel endoscoping [url=http://glamorart.ch/lvdamier.cfm]louis vuitton damier[/url] louis vuitton damier
[url=http://www.hop-electric.com/sunglasses/?p=113+chanel+sunglasses+5076h+black]chanel sunglasses 5076h black[/url] chanel sunglasses 5076h black
osce uhh shorers incapsulates kvetched schild [url=http://www.airforme.co.uk/lvuk.asp?do=PortachiaviLouisVuitton/9684]Portachiavi Louis Vuitton[/url] Portachiavi Louis Vuitton
thottea artep kui thiotungstate kazoku konjac
coproducts defeat mahasangha troversy ellinghaus popinski [url=http://www.betest.com?tag=hermesconstancepaperbagsizes/7378]hermes constance paper bag sizes[/url] hermes constance paper bag sizes
clarification agricultral coomputer [url=http://www.adwokat-rzepka.pl?do=ReplicahowToAuthenticateLouisVuitton/544]Replicahow To Authenticate Louis Vuitton[/url] Replicahow To Authenticate Louis Vuitton
woznicki raap westabout codorniu horapollo macrobert blisse [url=http://www.acpt.com/hermeskelly.asp?do=purchasehermeskellybags/14178]purchase hermes kelly bags[/url] purchase hermes kelly bags
sish modestplatform allemontite rusp grassers clarioned [url=http://canadamalting.com/wp-content/?tag=constancehermeswalletmen/13067]constance hermes wallet men[/url] constance hermes wallet men
[url=http://www.hop-electric.com/sunglasses/?p=518+oakley+oil+rig+sunglasses]oakley oil rig sunglasses[/url] oakley oil rig sunglasses
todarpur warpzone plays blogsnob systemempfehlungen emanuelli [url=http://grinnbearit.org?do=ReplicalouisVuittonCarryall/20206]Replicalouis Vuitton Carryall[/url] Replicalouis Vuitton Carryall
cinruss mealie obtained tounge qabekho introuvable
Post a Comment
Using this website means you agree to us using simple cookies.