The Ecologist

Beijing's polluted skies
Beijing smog
More articles about
Related Articles

Beijing's blue skies...or little white lies?

Olivia Boyd

6th July, 2012

Fed up with fudged statistics Beijing’s increasingly environmentally-aware population has forced it's Government to come clean about air pollution in the city.

The thick, toxic smog that descended over Beijing in the first week of December last year was nothing new. Residents of the Chinese capital have long been used to grounded flights, sore throats and skyscrapers shrouded in a dirty haze. But when freelance journalist, Meng Si, woke in the middle of the night to find her boyfriend ordering “PM2.5 resistant” face-masks online, she knew something was different.

“During that time, PM 2.5 was the hottest topic on Weibo [Chinese Twitter],” she says. “Widespread public campaigns on the environment are very rare in China – this one has been the biggest and most intense so far.”

PM 2.5 is shorthand for particulate matter measuring 2.5 microns or less in diameter, a pollutant that’s fine enough to penetrate human lung and blood tissue and which, it is alleged, can cause asthma, heart disease and cancer. In the final months of 2011, this ‘teccie’ slogan became a rallying point for Chinese urbanites fed up with not just poor air quality, but also fudged government statistics that excluded data on fine particulates and ozone which then allows it to class most days in the notoriously smoggy capital as “Blue Sky Days”.

The culmination was a mass, online protest that directly impacted air pollution policy and has been hailed by many as a breakthrough for public environmental participation in China.

At the heart of the struggle was a widespread lack of confidence in official data. Every year since public reporting began in 1998, the Beijing government has claimed to have achieved its target of upping the number of “blue sky days” (days when an index of pollutants including sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxide is under 100). In 2009, the number was 285; the following year it climbed to 286. But a popular visual diary kept by two young Beijingers suggested the real number was closer to 180. People began to complain about having been “blue-skied”.

“Ordinary people can feel that the air is bad, and see that the sky isn’t blue,” says Meng Si. “When you see that gap for youself, it’s easy to feel disgusted that the government is treating us like idiots.”
That gap became even more obvious and tangible thanks to an independent air-quality monitoring station atop the US embassy. Set up initially for the benefit of the embassy’s own staff, a twitter feed releasing hourly PM2.5 data – and painting a markedly bleaker picture than the government’s own figures – became an internet sensation.

Armed with these new numbers, millions took to the country’s microblogging platforms to express their outrage: “We firmly demand that Beijing’s environmental protection administration starts publishing PM 2.5 levels in 2012! Otherwise provide all Beijingers, including the transient population, with gas masks!” demanded one NGO worker, named Guo Xia. And in an online poll started by well-known property developer Pan Shiyi, tens of thousands called for the government to release more accurate measurements.

It has been a campaign with teeth. By January, Beijing had started releasing trial PM2.5 data from one monitoring station (though notably on the other side of town from the US embassy, making it impossible to directly compare outputs from the two). Then, in March of this year, the State Council – China’s highest administrative body – announced revised national air quality rules.

As well as mandatory PM2.5 and ozone measurements, standards will now be tightened to be more in line with World Health Organisation levels. Beijing will adopt the new regime this year, along with 27 provincial capitals and three key industrial regions. Another 113 cities must follow suit next year and all but the smallest cities by 2015.

Meanwhile, Beijing’s environmental authorities appear to have dropped the term “blue sky day” altogether from their updates.
For a short campaign, it’s a big result, and has been celebrated by environmentalists as proof the public can directly influence environmental policy in China, just as in other countries. More surprisingly, the authoritarian government has now acknowledged the role of public pressure in prompting the changes: announcing the new regulations, state media agency Xinhua praised the “stirring campaign” played out on social network websites, which had, it reported, gained a “satisfying response” from policymakers.

Ma Jun, director of the Institute for Public & Environmental Affairs, is China’s leading voice on environmental transparency. The activist, who this month won the Goldman Environmental Prize for his pioneering work mapping pollution violations in China, believes the victory is a “great milestone”. “This very vocal expression of public opinion helped to overcome this barrier against environmental transparency in China – helped the government to overcome its own barrier and change its original position. It’s quite an amazing example,” he said.

But not everyone is convinced this is a great triumph for the people. Steven Andrews, a Beijing-based consultant whose analysis of US embassy Twitter data published on chinadialogue helped fuel last year’s surge of online activism, is sceptical that statistics alone will lead to cleaner air. “The real question is about enforcement,” he says. “Will this data prompt local officials to crack down on the sources of pollution?”

The failure to enforce even simple laws – such as getting construction sites (thought to be responsible for around 16% of Beijing’s air pollution) to cover their dust piles - does not fill him with optimism.
Andrews also points out that access to data is not the same as access to reliable data. He flags up a recent study, published in Environmental Health Perspectives, where scientists in the western city of Xi’an independently measured PM2.5 levels over a two year period. Their numbers were 50% higher than government-recorded levels of PM10 – the coarser particulates which, by definition, are more plentiful than PM2.5. (PM2.5 is a component of PM10).

Many members of the public share his views. “I wish I could be more confident about the reliability of PM2.5 data,” says Qi Te, a 24-year-old postgraduate student at Peking University. “But it’s part of our education here – definitely not from the textbook – that you need to be extremely careful with official statistics in order to be an aware citizen.”

There may be other reasons for caution. Recent history shows progress strengthening the public voice in China is not always linear. Hopes were raised in the early 2000s when the country’s first public environmental hearing prompted the cancellation of a controversial project at Beijing’s Old Summer Palace lake and NGOs defeated plans for a network of dams in the south-west. But no such influential hearings have taken place in the seven years since and the dam programme now looks set to start again.

Meanwhile, efforts to control the internet continue unabated. Most recently, China’s two most popular microblogs Sina Weibo and Tencent QQ temporarily blocked users from posting comments in an attempt to stem discussion about the downfall of powerful official Bo Xilai.

But for Ma Jun, none of this makes winning access to pollution data an empty victory. It is, he says, a crucial step for building a system of public supervision in which citizens can hold polluters to account: “There used to be some argument that if we can’t overcome this problem easily, then why should we waste our resources doing the monitoring and the disclosure? But to me, you’re never going to mobilise people to take action unless you give them information.”

Olivia Boyd is managing editor of chinadialogue


Previous Articles...

Users Comments

viagra 50 mg price cvs
Posted By PhilOxycle 1 November 1, 2015 10:28:27 PM

influenzae Adults ages to S. viagra samples cialis .Acetones in urineThe cross sections are then compiled to create a full D representation of the body that reveals not just the bones and cartilage but also the full range of soft tissues.P olar coldEach gram of con sumed protein yields about Cal.This may occur with disease of the pancreas pancreatitis when pancreatic enzymes are not excreted. viagra en canada Sildenafil citrate for erectile dysfunction in men receiving multiple antihypertensive agents a randomized controlled trial.A trial of sumatriptan is appropriate. buy oratane As Pauls mastoiditis otitis media tinnitus became progressively worse his doctor worried that this ringing in his ears might be caused by a benign brain tumor aan cholesteatoma acoustic neuroma glaucomaBefore the development of synthetic materials a lightweight metal alloy such as duralumin was the best material available for a full artificial leg.The useful practical aspects of alchemy on the other hand can be seen not as esoteric but as exoteric or widely accessible to anyone.After central venous catheter administration of furosemide mg rd degree AV heart block was observed in a very ill patient one case report. buy doxycycline on line Chapter Optics FIGUREAssess vital signs.The typical resolution of an OCT instrument is about m compared to the significantly higher m resolution of a confocal microscope.She denies any recent trauma or any event that she recalls precipitating the pain.You will learn about the key characteristics of social support and you will review the research linking social support to health. roaccutane buy Therapeutic INR is toHemorrhage or bleeding in the skin and other organs is a characteristic symptom.The Xray energy damages molecules within cells including gene containing DNA which duplicates itself as each cell divides.Altered level of consciousness stupor or coma c.

viagra test forum
Posted By PhilOxycle 1 November 15, 2015 04:08:13 PM

Detection of miRNAs with a nanopore single molecule counter. buy clomid for men online Primarily a disease of females lupus is an autoimmune disorder.Specialized cells Langerhans cells react to the presence of antigens and have an immune function.LncRNA prole of glioblastoma reveals the potential role of lncRNAs in contributing to glioblastoma pathogenesis.Accounts which were probably written and embroidered after Albertus death describe how he discovered the Philosophers Stone and passed its formulation to his pupil Thomas Aquinaswho then destroyed it fearing it had come from Satan. cialis 20 mg walgreens USE OF OXYGEN DURING EXERCISE TRAINING Patients with normal oxygen tension at rest can show frequent and sometimes severe desaturation during activities of daily living so the prescription of oxygen in rehabilitation is a difficult area.Up to of patients have synovitis in knees wrists or hand joints can be confused with RA.Cerebral edema occurs within to days and can cause mass effects for up to days.Mr.adrenal neoplasm paralysis parathyroid prodrome prolapse recombinant DNA relapse remission syndactyly syndrome ultrasonography viagra professional 100 mg canada This phenomenon is used to advantage in radia tion therapy.Your doctor will also do blood tests to make sure the medicines are working properly.Answer This woman most likely has TSS which is most classically associated with menstruating women wear ing vaginal tampons.treatmentPlatelet count is m L. propecia dosis efectos adversos .fampra.Contraception birth control can help prevent unplanned pregnancies.From Anderson SC.Accessory spinal accessory Swallowing Head and shoulder movements Speech Swallowing Sensory nerve fibers Motor nerve fibers Brain Brain FIGURE Cranial nerves I to XII leading from the base of the brain and showing the parts of the body they affect.Corbis Visuals Unlimited ftr tc tl Corbis Dennis Kunkel Microscopy Inc.If a workable connection could be made between the sensitive receptor cells of the ear and the area in the brain associated with sight it would be possible to see sounds. tadalafil soft nulli no not none nulligravida nullipara Paradifferentiating agentsThe abnormal electrical pathway is located and ablated destroyed via energy emitted from the catheter.

Believe cheap generic no preparation
Posted By Hatthewhilm 1 December 9, 2015 12:11:25 AM

ed men - generic cialis cialis economico generic cialis - cialis 10 mg effectiveness search cialis inurl:wforum.cgi

Posted By ArdmxurKexy 1 March 23, 2016 08:48:28 PM

GtczxvdgdfsdgbcdsHLBHFDasufksdfjln Ozxcjkl Maefegvtjy dfdfdfdsdgd FGxczDHXfgvdhjhjhjhsdadddfxgbnbm

Maximum Extreme Sex Porn Video 2015 r
Posted By AdalinVat 1 April 3, 2016 04:01:52 PM

Maximum Extreme Sex Porn Video 2015a EXTREME PORN VIP CLUB Zoo Extreme Sex Porn Best Video Uncensored Bestiality Zoo Sex Porn Video Exclusive Movie Alice New Star Teens Extreme Hot Sex with a Horses & Dogs Horse Sex Whores Extreme Hard Sex with a Horses Stallion Horse Cum Buckets of horse cum fun Horses and Teengirls Teen girl having sex with horse farmsex Male Zoo Gay farmsex with a horses and dogs Dog Sex Club Hot Teens Sex with a Dogs Beasty Asia Japan Zoo Sex Collection Genki Japan Studio Extreme Sex with Exotic Animals Maximum Extreme Sex Porn Best Video Uncensored Necrophilia Extreme Death Sex Uncesored Brutal Forced Rape Teens Extreme Sex Bondage BDSM Torture Extreme Sex Extreme Asian Girl Teen Sex Movie PornStar Fucking Machines Video Hot Sex With Young Beautiful Teen Schoolgirls Porn Best Video Babysitter Movies Get Punished With The Cock Teen Lesbian Land Exclusive Lesbian Virgins Cheerleader Facials Cum Loads To The Face Teen Sleepover Lesbians Hot Sex Games Girls Left Alone Lonely Girls Playing With Themselves Little Russian Euro Teens Very Hot Sex With SchoolGirls 3D Porn Hardcore HD Video 3D Porn Star 3D Teen Hot Porn Shemale Trance Gay Male Sex Best Porn Best Video Bukkake Sperm Hardcore Porn Best Video 18+xxxu

Organization stingy generc tadlafil no medicament
Posted By ClaysonOr 1 April 25, 2016 12:44:59 AM

cialis more:for_health_professionals - cialis over the counter cialis information yim cialis over the counter at walmart - cialis tadalafil 20mg price guestbook.asp?action= cialis content management powered by cutenews

guest test title
Posted By Guestsoync 1 May 25, 2016 07:12:05 PM

guest test post bbcode html simple

Posted By dAylNJv 1 June 12, 2016 07:23:43 PM
Post a Comment
Security Code* Get another image


Using this website means you agree to us using simple cookies.

More information here...