The Ecologist

 
Tom Hodgkinson
Tom Hodgkinson. Photo by Chris Floyd
More articles about
Related Articles

No-one put Keats on a well-being course and a dose of Prozac

Tom Hodgkinson

4th March, 2010

An obsession with happiness science is just the chemistry set for a new opiate of the masses. Give me misery, says Tom Hodgkinson

There is nothing so cheering as gloom, and since at least the 1380s, our commentators, whether they be priests, poets or pundits, have repeatedly asserted that life is about pain and woe. I find it is immensely uplifting to read their doom-laden words, whereas books about happiness are deeply depressing.

Towards the end of the medieval age, the people began to grow restless. There was the Peasants’ Revolt of 1381, where the bold English peasantry protested against rising poll tax and the removal of some of their old liberties. Wat Tyler was stabbed by the Lord Mayor of London on the 15th of June, and indeed there is a movement afoot in anarchist circles to declare a 'Wat Tyler' day in remembrance of this liberty-seeker.

At around the same time, the theologians seemed pretty gloomy as well. Priest John Mirk put together a collection of sermons called the Festial. On page one, he declared that men and women live 'forto be borne yn sykenes, forto lyven yn travayle, and forto dye in drede' (born in sickness, live in toil, die in fear).

Enter the stormtroopers


After the Reformation, it seemed that things grew even worse. In 1540, just five years after Henry VIII’s stormtroopers smashed up the cathedrals, churches, monasteries and convents, writer John Burgoyne declared that 'the lif of man in this wretched world is shorte, uncertain and transitory'.

Then of course we have in 1624 the great Robert Burton, and his best-selling Anatomy of Melancholy, seven hundred pages of closely typeset misery and a 17th century best-seller. He expressed Man’s plight thus:

My pain’s past cure, another hell,
I may not in this torment dwell!
Now desperate I hate my life,
Lend me a halter or a knife
All my griefs to this are jolly,
Naught so damned as melancholy.


It is perhaps not a coincidence that at the time of Burton's writing, the fun-hating Puritans were in ascent, and were waging a ferocious battle against the old festive culture by abolishing all the old feast days.

 



Agree, disagree? Leave your comment here

 



Don't medicine Keats

In the mid-eighteenth century, our famous lexicographer Dr Johnson appeared addicted to misery, writing of the life of the Grub Street hack:

Mark what ills the scholar’s life assail,
Toil, envy, want, the patron and the jail.


In the early 19th century we have Keats writing an ode to melancholy, where he suggested that melancholy dwells with both joy and beauty. It’s a beautiful poem and thankfully no well-meaning self-esteem counsellors intervened and put Keats on a well-being course with a side order of Prozac.

There is the contemporary French slogan 'Métro Boulot Dodo', which sums up the boredom that characterizes daily life for most city-bound toilers, and was inspired by the line 'métro, boulot, bistro, mégots, dodo, zéro' from a poem by Pierre Béarn, written in 1951. Get on the tube, work all day, go to sleep: and so the cycle goes on and on. Eighties rockers The Godfathers titled their 1988 LP 'Birth School Work Death' to make a similar point.

Arbeit macht frei?

It is the sense of slavery, I think, that creates the gloom: the feeling that you are not in control of your own life. This certainly lay behind the Peasants’ Revolt. The church has argued that the answer is to seek escape not in this life but in the hereafter. John Mirk told the peasants that they would get their comeuppance against the lawyers and bishops in heaven. In our own age, we are a little more impatient, and the response of the academics and the state has been to create a science of happiness. Individual happiness, it seems, not service or improving the world around you: that is the goal of life. Thus it is that the founders of America insisted on the 'right' to 'the pursuit of happiness' in Jefferson’s Declaration of Independence.

Today we have professors who write books about how to be happy. They are consulted by our totalitarian state which then tries to teach happiness in schools. It is all a load of dangerous hokum firstly because it does not work, and secondly because it replaces political struggle: if you were unhappy with your wages and conditions at work in the seventies, you might well go on strike. Today, your union will offer you counselling.  This state of affairs was predicted in 1946 by Aldous Huxley when he predicted that we would see 'vast government-sponsored enquiries into what the politicians and the participating scientists will call "the problem of happiness" — in other words, the problem of making people love their servitude'. The commercial world weighs in with the slogan 'lovin’ it', which helps do the same thing: 'I’m loving slavery! It’s wicked!'

The pursuit of happiness leads to the oppposite. Happiness comes as a by-product of other pursuits: helping people, making beautiful things, digging the garden, and of course in the contemplation of the wretchedness and absurdity of human life.

Tom Hodgkinson is editor of the Idler

Add to StumbleUpon
  READ MORE...
COMMENT
Stuff your face like a pre-Reformation Christian
We've inherited an unhealthy, puritan attitude to food and sensory pleasure, says Tom Hodgkinson. Taking a leaf out of the books of our medieval ancestors would do us all good...
COMMENT
Look at 'real wealth' and you'll see we're getting poorer
Politicians talk a good green economy, but when it comes down to it, they're still only interested in seeing the GDP figures tick upwards...
HOW TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE
10 approaches to tackling over-consumption
'There is enough for everyone’s need, but not for everyone’s greed,’ said Gandhi – but how much does each of us need?
HOW TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE
Buy nothing day
Buy Nothing Day is an annual event to protest our consumerist culture. Consumers are encouraged across the world to stay out of malls and put their wallets back in their pockets for just one day. Started back in 1992 in Vancouver, Canada by Ted Dave, it was popularized by the Adbusters media foundation and it has spread to become an international day of action.
INVESTIGATION
The leisure economy: can we save the planet by working less?
The idea of a 'leisure economy' has been predicted for decades, but never realised. Despite this, research shows that our working habits continue to put a strain on the planet's resources. Could tackling climate change be as simple as working less?

 

Previous Articles...

ECOLOGIST COOKIES

Using this website means you agree to us using simple cookies.

More information here...

 

FOLLOW
THE ECOLOGIST