The use of neonicotinoid Clothianidin by farmers may pose a long-term toxic risk to bees, say scientists
Leaked document exposes risks to bees and insects from Bayer pesticide
3rd January, 2010
US government scientists flag up risks to bees and aquatic insects from neonicotinoid pesticide that biotech giant Bayer are trying to gain approval for use by farmers
Biotech giant Bayer CropScience is seeking approval for a neonicotinoid pesticide whose use poses a potential 'long-term toxic risk' to honeybees and an 'acute and chronic risk' to freshwater invertebrates, according to a leaked document from the US Environment Protection Agency (EPA).
Neonicotinoid pesticides are a comparatively new group of synthetic chemicals used as a coating for agricultural seeds and in pot plants. The chemicals spread throughout the plant and into the nectar and pollen to kill insects attacking the plant. Bayer are seeking approval from the EPA to allow the use of the neonicotinoid Clothianidin, an insecticide, on cotton and mustard seeds.
Campaign groups including the Soil Association and Buglife claim the use of neonicotinoids on crops expose insects to levels of the chemical that is enough to weaken their immune system and in the case of bees, affect their ability to forage and breed.
'At the levels people were recording in the field when then applied to bees in a laboratory it had a significant impact on there behaviour,' said Buglife CEO Matt Shardlow. 'It's not the same as killing them but enough to stop them foraging and so they will die out.'
Although not recommending a ban, EPA scientists said existing Bayer-funded field studies on the impact on aquatic life, from the leaching of the chemical into the soil, and honey bees were inadaquate. They cited an incident in Germany in 2008 where clothianidin, not properly applied to sweetcorn seeds, was allowed to drift off from seed planting equipment killing millions of honeybees.
Bayer reject EPA and campaigners fears and say only those insects biting into the plant and trying to destroy it would be adversely affect. 'Bees drink the nector and pollen but the levels they are exposed to are extremely tiny and well within safety limits,' said spokesperson Dr Julian Little. Aquatic life would also be unaffected, he said, as only a small amount of the chemical could come off the surface of the seed once it had been applied and therefore the amount of leaching would be minimal.
A number of campaign groups, including Pesticide Action Network (PAN) and Buglife said they would now be putting renewed pressure on government agencies in the US and Europe to ban neonicotinoids in 2011. 'The tide is turning against these chemicals but the decision-makers appear reluctant to step in,' said Shardlow.
Full leaked EPA document
Buglife report on the impact of neonicotinoid insecticides on bees
‘Growing body of evidence’ links pesticides to bee decline
Government and retailers, including B&Q and Wyevale, under pressure to impose a ban on sale of pesticides linked to bee population decline following new research
Agri-chemical companies are both breeding and killing bees
Agri-chemical companies like Syngenta don’t just make the chemicals that have been blamed for the decline in bees; they also breed the bees that are being used as a replacement for wild pollinators
Controversial pesticides linked to 'total ecological collapse' of insects and birds
Widespread use of insecticides affecting bee populations but also causing decline in numbers of birds, butterflies and moths, warns Dutch toxicologist
Loss of forage biggest long-term threat to bees
Intensification of farming and subsequent decline in food sources rather than pesticides or disease seen as biggest threat to honey bees
|HOW TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE
How to be an urban beekeeper
You don't need a smallholding and a meadow to be a budding apiarist - a few sensible precautions will let you fight honeybee decline with a hive in your own backyard
Using this website means you agree to us using simple cookies.