The Wave Hub energy scheme is being tested off the Cornish coast
- Special Investigation: How bullying and intimidation in abattoirs threatens food safety checks
- Join the Resurgence Trust and help keep The Ecologist as a free service
- Lies, damned lies and twisted statistics - fake science set to kill 100,000 English badgers
- False promise: nuclear power: past, present and (no) future
Making waves: how the UK is showing the way on low-impact wave technology
21st December, 2010
Following announcements by two UK-based companies, wave power looks set to become an increasingly important renewable energy source. But how long will it be before it is commercially viable and what ecological benefits might it bring?
The UK enjoys the richest marine energy resource in Europe, with, according to government figures, approximately 35 per cent of the continent’s total wave-energy potential. The Carbon Trust estimates that we could meet up to 15 per cent of our electricity needs from marine sources, installing two gigawatts (GW) of generation capacity by 2020, and up to 30GW by 2050.
As a result of this unique potential, many in the renewables sector are waking up to the fact that wave power could one day rival wind as a key source of renewable energy in Britain. In its 2010 study Building a Low Carbon Economy: The UK's Innovation Challenge, the Committee on Climate Change reports that the UK has become a world leader in the sector with ‘a quarter of the world’s wave technologies being developed to some extent in the UK.’
Despite this early promise, however, the total amount of energy generated from wave power remains relatively modest. A new report by the Centre for Alternative Technology reveals that, in 2008, renewables were responsible for just 6 per cent of energy used (7 per cent of gross supplied electricity), with just 0.75 per cent from wind, wave and solar sources (although this accounted for almost 2 per cent of gross supplied electricity).
The fact remains that wave-power technology, which captures energy from wave movement and converts it into electricity, is still subject to uncertainties over the best system design, and faces substantial challenges over issues including installation, maintenance and grid connection.
New wave technologies
Against this background, two innovative UK projects are rising to the challenge of developing the technologies necessary to realise this massive, and as yet largely untapped, energy resource.
In November, E.ON UK revealed that its prototype wave power device, the Vagr Atferd, (meaning ‘wave power’), had generated power in UK waters for the first time - hailed by Scottish first minister Alex Salmond as 'another step' in Scotland's journey to becoming the 'green energy powerhouse of Europe'.
Currently on trial in Orkney, the 750kW device is first of its type to be tested anywhere in the world. At 180m, long the Pelamis Wave Energy Converter weighs approximately 1,300 tonnes and works by using wave motion to produce electricity by driving a set of hydraulic rams at the hinged joints, which link the cylindrical sections of the device.
Meanwhile, the team behind Wave Hub, an energy scheme with the potential to generate enough electricity to power as many as 17,500 homes, announced last month that it has been plugged into the National Grid for the first time.
The Hub is a £42 million grid-connected offshore facility for the large-scale testing of technologies that generate electricity via wave power. It consists of an electrical hub on the seabed 16km off the Cornish coast, to which wave-energy devices can be connected. The 12-tonne hub is linked to the UK’s grid network via a 25km, 1,300-tonne undersea cable.
From trial to commercial use
So how long will it be before wave technology of this type is available on a large scale? According to Guy Lavender, Wave Hub’s business manager, commercial development depends upon a range of factors, from the availability of adequate finance to the establishment of a supportive regulatory and consenting regime for long-term development.
'It is important to recognise that device developers are at different stages of development. Whereas some are confident of commercial deployment in the next five years, others believe that it could be 10 years before we see large-scale commercial arrays,' says Lavender.
Developers will also need marine licences for commercial-scale projects, which can only be obtained after carrying out environmental impact assessments.
Assuming these hurdles are overcome, Lavender argues that a number of other constraints to scaling up the technology remain. These range from the technical challenges of offshore deployment and the development of nearshore grid capacity to the need to develop a supportive planning and regulatory system.
'Wave Hub responds to many of these issues by showing how an offshore infrastructure project can and has been delivered. What is important, however, is that there is a clear commitment from the UK government that this is an industry it wants to build. Without that the UK risks losing its competitive advantage,' adds Lavender.
E.ON UK’s approach is gradually to expose the Vagr Atferd to increasingly severe sea states to prove the machine can operate in the full range of conditions.
'We need to do this in a series of stages to manage exposure, build up confidence and gather the operating data that we and our partners need,' says Amaan Lafayette, marine development manager at E.ON UK, who adds that the testing programme is expected to last for between four and five years.
Impact on marine wildlife
In the wake of ongoing debates about the environmental consequences of wave and tidal power, industry figures argue that smaller-scale devices, such as the Vagr Atferd and those tested at Wave Hub, will have less impact than larger-scale technologies such as the recently withdrawn plans for a Severn barrage.
'In broad terms, grid-connected open-sea infrastructure like Wave Hub is less capital-intensive than barrage technology and has less impact on the environment, given that wave-energy devices generally float on or just below the surface of the sea and only require mooring systems to keep them in place,' says Lavender.
At this stage, the environmental and ecological effects depend on the local area and are difficult to predict, especially as there aren’t yet many projects in the water available for monitoring and comparison. However, by creating a ‘total barrier effect’ it is difficult to deny that a barrage will also cause additional impacts over and above individual ‘non-connected’ devices.
'Fish will undoubtedly be [more] affected by a barrage than spaced devices, unless provision was made for them to pass through the barrage without passage through the turbines. This would then have a knock-on effect on the wider ecosystem by virtue of impacts on birds that may feed on the fish,' says Lafayette.
'Water quality [would also] be impacted as the sediment levels change, which will affect the turbidity of the water, and this will affect the animals that live in the water basin or estuary,' he adds.
Marine campaigners are also broadly supportive of the advantages of wave technologies. A recent Marine Conservation Society (MCS) co-ordinated report outlined how offshore wind, wave and tidal could be developed in Scotland without endangering 'important environmental interests'.
'While the site-specific impacts are yet to be fully understood, we are confident that if placed sensitively and executed with care, wave-energy devices such as Pelamis should be truly sustainable developments,' says Melissa Moore, MCS senior policy officer.
|HOW TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE
Whisky and waves: the future of Scottish isle's power?
Communities on the Isle of Islay are moving forward with plans for tidal energy and renewable fuels while maintaining age old methods of agriculture and whisky distilling
Zero carbon Britain: how to get there in 10 steps
A blueprint for how Britain could reduce its greenhouse gas emissions to zero over the next 20 years by a combination of electrification, insulation and a massive scaling up of offshore wind
How France eclipsed the UK with Brittany tidal success story
The UK may have turned its back on the Severn barrage but across the channel they have been harnessing tidal energy from the River Rance for more than 40 years - and it may yet point to a way forward for smaller-scale renewable projects
Power On - Tidal Power
The potential for the use of tidal power in the UK is enormous, amounting to, at the very least, 20 per cent of our electricity needs.
Aberdeen turns from oil to renewables
Aberdeen attempts to move away from dependence on declining oil stocks with opening of new green energy centre
Using this website means you agree to us using simple cookies.